Why a Madhhab?
Having understood the definition of the madhhab, we need to know: when we have the Quran and Hadith, what is the need for a madhhab?
The answer is this: in the definition of the madhhab we discussed that the madhhab essentially deals with branch matters that are not conclusively established or clear in the evidence. Now we need to know what those branch matters are. Once that is clear, it will be understood what need there is, and how much, for a madhhab when we have the Quran and Hadith.
I will present the matter through one ruling and a real incident of my own.
While I was in Madinah, on a hot midsummer afternoon as the day was fading, I was sitting under the rows of date palms around the hall of the University of Madinah, reading the Bengali translation of Surah an-Nur. This surah, rich in various rulings of the Sharia, is wonderful to read and take to heart. Read it once and you cannot help but love it!
Anyway, as I read the Bengali translation of Surah an-Nur, at one point I came to the verse below and stopped short. I could not go any further –
الزَّانِي لَا يَنْكِحُ إِلَّا زَانِيَةً أَوْ مُشْرِكَةً وَالزَّانِيَةُ لَا يَنْكِحُهَا إِلَّا زَانٍ أَوْ مُشْرِكٌ وَحُرِّمَ ذَلِكَ عَلَى الْمُؤْمِنِينَ
Surah an-Nur, verse no. 3
Bengali translation - "The adulterer does not marry except an adulteress or a polytheist woman, and the adulteress does not marry except an adulterer or a polytheist man, and that has been made unlawful for the believers."
I was greatly astonished by the Bengali translation! Two questions were circling in my head –
1. Allah is saying that one adulterer should marry another adulteress. But how does that work? How would I know who is an adulterer and who is pure?
2. He says a polytheist marries an adulterer.
Yet in another verse Allah the Exalted has forbidden marriage with polytheists – for example,
ولا تنكحوا المشركات حتى يؤمن
That is, "Do not marry polytheistic women until they believe." Surah al-Baqarah, verse no. 221
I was in great trouble! In one verse Allah speaks of marriage with polytheists, and in another of a prohibition! What is going on!
Then a thought came to my mind,
It is not possible for me to understand everything in the Quran from a Bengali translation alone. Hundreds of books of tafsir have been written to understand this Quran. Thousands of hadiths contain explanations of the Quran. So it is not possible for me to fully understand the Quran by merely reading Bengali.
I thought, let me take the help of Tafsir Ibn Kathir. As soon as I opened the tafsir, I saw that Ibn Kathir (RA) says –
قال عبد الله بن عباس : ليس هذا بالنكاح، إنما هو الجماع
I was stunned! All my life I had read that the meaning of نكاح is marriage, and now I learned that the other meaning of nikah is جماع, that is, sexual intercourse!
Anyway, this is the tafsir of a Companion (RA); there is no way not to accept it. So now the full explanation of the verse is –
"An adulterer will commit a wicked act with another adulteress woman, or with a polytheist. A good, righteous servant of Allah cannot do this."
I reached a reasonable understanding. But many more things were circling in my mind. But I could not tell where, or by reading what, I would find the answers.
Then a question arose in my mind -
All right, let us accept that nikah here means intercourse. But what then is the ruling on the marriage of an adulterer and an adulteress?
I read all the explanation of the above verse in Tafsir Ibn Kathir. I did not find a complete solution. I thought: I did not find it clearly in the Quran, and I did not find it in the Hadith either, because if it were in the Hadith, Ibn Kathir (RH) would usually mention it. I did not find it there either. Then only the books of fiqh remained!
I ran from the date grove to my room. From the books of fiqh lying scattered on the table, I picked up 'Bidayat al-Mujtahid'!
I found the chapter on marriage. Turning the pages one by one, I began searching for the above ruling. At one point I saw written –
ما حكم نكاح الزاني / الزانية ؟
What is the ruling on the marriage of an adulterer / adulteress?
Then I was very happy to find the solution to the ruling. However, although the ruling looks easy this way, it is very complicated in the apparent wording of the Quran!
The gist is this –
It will not be valid for a righteous and pure man ever to marry an adulterous woman. Since Allah has clearly said in the Holy Quran that an adulterer cannot marry anyone other than an adulteress. But if that woman / man sincerely repents to Allah, then marriage with them is permissible. Because the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said –
التائب من الذنب كمن لا ذنب له
"One who repents sincerely becomes as though he had no sin." Ibn Majah, 4250
According to the Hadith, if an adulterer/adulteress repents, their sin is forgiven. As a result they become righteous and pure like other people. Therefore, if the adulterer/adulteress repents, then marriage with them is lawful. And this is the view of Imam al-A'zam Abu Hanifa (RA) and most of the scholars.
Think about it,
How easily the mujtahid scholars solved a difficult ruling! And that very solution is what is called the madhhab. So you must have understood by now why the madhhab came, or why the madhhab was devised even though we have the Quran and Hadith.
See one more thing: for most rulings of the Quran and Hadith, the level, that is, whether it is fard, wajib, sunnah or mubah, or haram, makruh and so on, is not clearly stated in the Quran and Hadith. The imams of the madhhabs researched and determined these and made them clear.
In short, the solutions arrived at through the research of the mujtahid scholars, on matters where there is no direct or clear statement in the Quran and Hadith, are called the madhhab.
Yet in our society there are some brothers who say, "Why a madhhab when we have the Quran and Hadith?" Dear brother, the madhhab did not come for those matters in the Quran and Hadith that are clearly stated. On matters that are clearly addressed, the imams have ittifaq, that is, agreement. The madhhab came essentially -
1 - To clarify what is unclear.
2 - To resolve mutual contradictions.
3 - To explain what is khass (specific) and what is 'amm (general).
4 - To explain what is abrogated and what remains in force.
5 - To give solutions to all newly arising issues.
6 - To lay down a principle in the light of the Quran and Hadith for solving all possible future problems.
7 - To preserve the unity and solidarity of the Ummah. That is, so that no one, in the name of following the Quran and Hadith, can create disorder by giving various opinions.
Many people, without understanding, think that the madhhab is a third thing like the Quran and Hadith. This is a baseless and mistaken idea. The fundamental and primary sources of the Sharia are the Quran and Hadith. The madhhab only clearly shows the correct path and method for following the Quran and Hadith. Nothing else.