Chapter One · The Madhhab

Can One Follow a Stronger Opinion Without Following a Specific Madhhab?

For an ordinary person, taking the strongest opinion from all the madhhabs without following any specific madhhab is nothing but a futile effort and a cry in the wilderness. I will discuss this below with evidence, insha Allah. First, let me say a few words by way of introduction.

Wanting to take the strongest opinion from all the madhhabs without following any specific madhhab means aspiring to something impossible. Because,

1. If the strongest opinion were clear and easy to determine, there would have been no need for the four madhhabs to be devised. There would have been no need for so many views and paths to arise.

2. If the strongest opinion were clear, a madhhab would have been drawn up from all the strongest opinions so far, and it would be called the Strongest Madhhab. But in history this Strongest Madhhab has not yet been born.

3. If the strongest opinion could be extracted readily, a book of fiqh would have been written containing all these strongest opinions. But no absolute book of fiqh has been written so far that rises above disagreement.

Now to the main discussion. Yes! The statement is true; but implementing it is hard. There is an English proverb: To say is easy but to do is hard.

There are two reasons for it:

1. Disagreement, or the madhhab, came precisely to discover the opinion closest to the Quran and Hadith on unclear and complex matters. So will you now discover yet another new madhhab?

2. Since the creation of the madhhabs, scholars have tried in every era to see whether any madhhab closer to the Quran and Sunnah than the four can be made. But to this day no one has been able to. So be sure that you will not be able to either.

In short, saying "I act on what is closest to the Quran and Sunnah" ___ is as easy to say with the mouth as it is hard to implement in practice. All these disagreements arose precisely over determining the closest view; so what new disagreement will you create now?

Let us see an example.

What is the ruling on reciting Surah al-Fatihah behind the imam in an obligatory prayer? There is much discussion on this in the Quran and Hadith.

Allah the Exalted has said -

" وإذا قرئ القرآن فاستمعوا له وأنصتوا لعلكم ترحمون "

Meaning: And when the Quran is recited, listen to it attentively and be silent, that you may receive mercy.

On this verse, the statement of Ibn Abbas (RA) is quoted in Tafsir al-Tabari (vol. 9, p. 103) and Tafsir Ibn Kathir (vol. 2, p. 28) as follows -

وإذا قرئ القرآن فاستمعوا له وأنصتوا لعلكم ترحمون " يعني في الصلاة المفروضة

Meaning: When the Quran is recited, listen to it attentively and be silent, that you may receive mercy, that is, in the obligatory prayer.

The view of Ibn Mas'ud (RA) is the same. It is said in Tafsir al-Tabari:

صلى ابن مسعود، فسمع أناسا يقرءون مع الامام، فلما انصرف، قال: أما آن لكم أن تفقهوا ؟ أما آن لكم أن تعقلوا ؟ وإذا قرئ القرآن فاستمعوا له وأنصتوا كما أمركم الله

That is, Ibn Mas'ud (RA) was praying, and heard some people reciting along with the imam. After the prayer he said: Has the time not come for you to realise, has the time not come for you to understand? When the Quran is recited, listen to it attentively and be silent, as Allah has commanded you. (vol. 9, p. 103)

Zayd ibn Aslam and Abu al-Aliyah (RH) said:

كانوا يقرأون خلف الإمام فنزلت : وإذا قرئ القرآن فاستمعوا له وأنصتوا لعلكم ترحمون

That is, they (the Companions) used to recite behind the imam, and then was revealed

وإذا قرئ القرآن فاستمعوا له وأنصتوا لعلكم ترحمون

Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal (RH) said:

أجمع الناس على أن هذه الآية في الصلاة

That is, all agree on this, that this verse was revealed concerning prayer. (Masa'il Ahmad li-Abi Dawud, p. 48)

In short, from the above discussion it was understood that one cannot recite qira'ah behind the imam in prayer.

Now let us see the opposite view.

The famous hadith -

لا صلاة لمن لم يقرأ بفاتحة الكتاب

That is - whoever does not recite Surah al-Fatihah in prayer, his prayer is not valid.

This is a famous hadith, about which no one has any doubt. So, brothers, now think. The above discussion proves that one need not recite qira'ah behind the imam in prayer. And the hadith below proves that if one does not recite Surah al-Fatihah, the prayer will not be valid.

Now tell me, in this difficult matter of mutual contradiction, is it possible for you to reconcile and discover the view closest to the Quran and Sunnah?

Dear brother, if the view closest to the Quran and Sunnah in matters of disagreement could be found with perfect clarity, there would have been no need for the four madhhabs in Islam. There would have been no need for so many disagreements.

Final word, in matters of disagreement there is nothing that can fully establish one view as closest to the Quran and Sunnah. Nearly all the views of the four madhhabs are close to the Quran and Sunnah. That is why, among Ahl as-Sunnah wal-Jama'ah, all four madhhabs are sound and recognised. Following any one is enough.

Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah (rahimahullah) says –

'If someone likes one of the four madhhabs, it is not lawful for others to object to that. One who likes the Shafi'i madhhab cannot object to someone who likes the Maliki madhhab. Likewise, if someone likes the Hanbali madhhab, he cannot object to a follower of the Shafi'i madhhab or any other madhhab.'

Source - Majmu'at al-Fatawa 20/292

Final word, from the fatwa of Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah (rahimahullah) we clearly understood two things –

1 – All four madhhabs are on the truth. Any one of them may be followed.

2 – If someone follows one madhhab, he cannot be objected to.

Besides this, many of our brothers claim that Imam Abu Hanifa (RH) said: when a hadith is authentic, that is my madhhab. So what is the problem in taking the more authentic view of the four madhhabs?

I think a little discussion of this matter is necessary!

"When a hadith is authentic, that is my madhhab"

Isn't this statement very popular?

Isn't it the statement of Imam Abu Hanifa (RA)?

Yes! In our country this statement is strongly circulated in the name of Imam al-A'zam Abu Hanifa (RA), and it is also wrongly explained.

That is -

Two mistakes exist in this statement

1. Circulating the statement in the name of Imam al-A'zam Abu Hanifa (RA).

2. Giving a wrong explanation of the statement.

1. "When a hadith is authentic, that is my madhhab" - this sentence was not said by Imam al-A'zam Abu Hanifa (RA). Rather, this statement was said by Imam al-Shafi'i (RA) alone. That anyone else said such a thing ___ is not proven through a sound chain.

Source - al-Majmu', p. 64

Our religious brothers ask us to verify whether something is authentic / weak / fabricated when they get it, but have you ever considered that they circulate this statement in the name of Imam Abu Hanifa (RA) without verifying it?

2. The statement is wrongly explained. It is said - every imam said that if a hadith is authentic, that is my madhhab!

This is a completely wrong explanation. Rather, by this statement Imam al-Shafi'i (RA) meant that when a hadith is authentic in light of the hadith principles of his madhhab, then that has been / will be accepted as his authentic madhhab. Such an explanation exists in the usul books of the Shafi'i madhhab.

We know that the honoured imams of the Shafi'i madhhab were the first to research or write books on which hadith is authentic / weak or fabricated, that is, on usul al-hadith. So it is very natural for such a statement to come from Imam al-Shafi'i (RH)!

Now let us discuss a different point -

1. On one hand our brothers claim that no imam made a madhhab; rather, the madhhabs were devised long after their deaths. They also say that the imams of the madhhabs did not even know about the drawing up of their madhhabs.

On the other hand, our brothers go about saying that the imams of the madhhabs said - when a hadith is authentic, that is my madhhab.

My question is -

If the imams did not make or leave behind any madhhab, then how could they say that when a hadith is authentic, that is my madhhab??

Because this sentence says "my madhhab", that is, it announces that there is something like a madhhab determined by them!

On one hand our brothers say that the imams of the madhhabs did not make any madhhab. On the other hand they say that the imams of the madhhabs said - when a hadith is authentic, that is my madhhab!

Finally, I present a statement for my respected reader -

'An ordinary Muslim is sometimes deceived by himself. Reading books on his own, he starts to think he has become even greater than the scholars. After reading one or two rulings, or a book, posing as a scholar in society, he starts to think that in knowledge and understanding he is in no way less than the scholars. He even sometimes starts to think that his understanding is no less than that of Imam Abu Hanifa, Shafi'i, Maliki or Hanbali (RH).'

وهذا كلام صاحب المنعم الشيخ موسى شاهين في بداية السنة والتشريع

Besides this, many people go to great excess over one matter, that all the imams said –

"When a hadith is authentic, that is my madhhab"

On the strength of this one sentence, many consider themselves fully qualified in every field of hadith: that if a hadith is authentic, I will follow it. But to whom did the imam say this? Or what did he mean by it? Perhaps that is unknown to many.

What is the purpose of this statement?

Imam al-Nawawi (d. 676 AH) says -

وإنما هذا فيمن له رتبة الاجتهاد في المذهب وشرطه أن يغلب على ظنه أن الشافعي رحمه الله لم يقف على هذا الحديث أو لم يعلم صحته وهذا إنما يكون بعد مطالعة كتب الشافعي كلها ونحوه من كتب أصحابه الآخذين عنه وما أشبهها ، وهذا شرط صعب قلّ من يتصف به.

That is, this statement was said about a person who has reached the level of ijtihad within his madhhab. But the condition is that he must have nearly certain knowledge that al-Shafi'i (RH) did not become aware of the hadith, or did not gain knowledge of its authenticity. And this is possible only when he has studied all of al-Shafi'i's books, the books of his students, and some similar ones. This is a difficult condition that is found in very few people.

Source - al-Majmu', 1/104)

Hafiz Abu Amr ibn as-Salah (d. 643 AH) said,

وليس هذا بالهين ، فليس كل فقيه يسوغ له أن يستقل بالعمل بما يراه حجة من الحديث

That is, this work is not that easy. Not every jurist can do this: that whatever hadith he himself regards as authoritative, he should act on it entirely on his own.

Source - Adab al-Mufti wa al-Mustafti, 1/118)

Wallahul Musta'an