Chapter One · The Madhhab

Why a Madhhab When We Have the Quran and Hadith?

From start to finish I am a student of fiqh ash-shari'ah. In other words, my area of study is the rulings and issues of the Sharia and the comparative discussion of the four well-known madhhabs of Islam. As soon as I got the chance at the University of Madinah, an interest in studying this subject awoke in me. Finally, by Allah's mercy, I got that opportunity.

Seeing the title, many have already understood that this is a very common question that many people ask. So it is important for everyone to know the answer well. At the outset I request that you read the entire piece from beginning to end. May Allah the Exalted grant you the best reward!

Why a madhhab even though there are the Quran and Hadith (?) __ because, when we study the rulings and issues of the Sharia, we find countless nass, or original passages, of the Quran and Hadith, from which it is not possible for everyone to understand directly or derive rulings.

We find many verses of the Quran from which not everyone has the ability to derive rulings directly. We are compelled to read the explanation of some mufassir. We find many hadiths of the Messenger ﷺ from which not everyone has the ability to derive rulings directly. So we are compelled to learn the explanation of some muhaddith.

We find countless original passages of the Quran and Hadith from which it is not possible for us to derive the rulings of the Sharia directly. So we are compelled to do taqlid, that is, follow, the ijtihad, or research, of an honoured imam of some madhhab.

In the article "Why a Madhhab?" I discussed that there are some matters in the Quran from which rulings cannot be derived directly. We are compelled to do taqlid, or follow, the imams of the madhhab.

In the present article I will explain (insha Allah) that there are also many hadiths from which rulings cannot be derived or acted on directly. Rather, we are compelled to do taqlid, or follow, the imam of some madhhab.

So let us understand the matter right now.

In the chapter on buying and selling in the Sharia there is a famous ruling, whose Arabic name is - التسعير (at-Tas'ir).

Its literal meaning - to fix the price.

Its technical meaning - the fixing of the price of some commodity by the government or the market committee, and compelling both parties (buyer and seller) to buy and sell at it.

The ruling is - in the Sharia, is it permissible to fix the price of goods in this way?

Answer - nothing about this ruling is found directly in the Holy Quran. But a clear nass is found in the noble Hadith. It is -

قال النَّاسُ يا رسولَ اللَّهِ ، غلا السِّعرُ فسعِّر لَنا ، قالَ رسولُ اللَّهِ صلَّى اللَّهُ عليهِ وسلَّمَ : إنَّ اللَّهَ هوَ المسعِّرُ القابضُ الباسطُ الرَّازقُ ، وإنِّي لأرجو أن ألقَى اللَّهَ وليسَ أحدٌ منكُم يطالبُني بمَظلمةٍ في دمٍ ولا مالٍ

The main summary is -

Once in Madinah the prices of many goods rose. The Companions said to the Messenger ﷺ - O Messenger of Allah! Prices have risen. Fix prices for us. Tirmidhi, 1314

The Messenger ﷺ replied - Allah the Exalted is the one who fixes prices; He is the one who takes provision, the one who expands provision, and the Provider.

In short, at the Companions' request the Messenger ﷺ showed unwillingness to interfere in the rise of prices, saying that Allah the Exalted is the Provider; He is the one who takes provision back, so He is the one who fixes the price of everything.

Grade of the hadith: Sahih

Anyway, the clear wording of the hadith and the fatwa is -- it is not permissible for the government or the market to fix the price of any commodity. Since the Messenger ﷺ did not do so. The power to raise the price of goods belongs to Allah the Exalted alone.

On the other hand, if we act directly on the hadith, the questions that come to mind are:

1. Where has Allah the Exalted fixed the price of goods? What is the price of rice, lentils, wheat? Where is it mentioned in the Quran and Hadith?

2. Revelation has stopped. How will Allah the Exalted announce the prices of constantly new goods?

3. If the prices of goods are fixed by Allah, why do traders fix prices on their own, and why do scholars permit it?

4. In big supermarkets in the Arab world or Europe, the prices of all goods are fixed. How is that lawful?

In short, if we try to follow the hadith directly, thousands of such questions will buzz in our heads. We believe there is no need to entertain such pointless thoughts or questions. Although the apparent meaning of the hadith is one, its intended meaning is certainly different. If we search, we will find it, insha Allah.

No explanation of this hadith is found in the Quran or any other hadith. So now we will go directly to the ijtihad, the research laboratory, of the honoured imams of the madhhabs. We will see what explanation they give of this hadith, or what fatwa they give on the above ruling.

From the apparent view of the hadith, fixing the price of any commodity is not permissible. Because the Messenger ﷺ did not do so. By the agreement of the imams, it is permissible for the government or the market committee to fix the price of goods.

So for the time being we see that there is a contradiction between the hadith of the Messenger ﷺ and the fatwa of the imams. No, in truth there is no discrepancy. Rather, it is the inadequacy of our understanding. We will look at their statements and then understand that their research is indeed in accordance with the hadith and fully suited to reality.

On the question of whether it is permissible for the government to fix the price of goods ___ the honoured jurists are united in saying it is completely permissible, and it is now accepted by consensus in the Islamic Sharia.

The jurists' claim and their evidences -

1. In the hadith it has come that Allah is the one who fixes prices __ it does not mean that Allah the Exalted will fix the price of each commodity separately. And that is not befitting Allah the Exalted's majesty. Rather, the intended explanation of the hadith is - Allah the Exalted has given every person mature intellect and intelligence. On the other hand, He has commanded everyone to maintain justice. So that with their intellect and intelligence people will observe justice in everything. In buying and selling, hold complete 'adalah, or justice. And Allah the Exalted loves those who act justly. Because He Himself is the Just.

2. Another hadith of the Messenger ﷺ, and this is among the principles of the Islamic Sharia -

(( لا ضرر ولا ضرار في الإسلام ))

That is, in Islam there is no room to be harmed or to harm anyone.

Grade of the hadith: Hasan

The honoured jurists say: if the government does not fix the price of goods, then, seeing the time and opportunity, some dishonest traders or syndicates will raise the prices of goods and put the general public in hardship. This is completely haram, that is forbidden, in Islam!

3. If the prices of the mentioned goods are not fixed by the government, prices may differ from place to place. That is complete discrimination and injustice. And in Islam there is no place for injustice or discrimination.

For all these reasons, and in the interest of the broad welfare of the Ummah (which is counted as one of the principles of the Sharia - عام مصلحة الناس), the imams of the four honoured madhhabs of Islam have permitted, or given legitimacy to, the fixing of the price of goods by the government or the market committee. Although it conflicts with the apparent meaning of the hadith, it is fully reasonable with the principles of Islam and the intended meaning of the hadith!

Falillahil hamd - in following the madhhab in order to follow the complete Sharia, we never get into difficulty, and there is no possibility at all of getting into difficulty until the Day of Resurrection, insha Allah. Because the honoured imams of the madhhabs, in the light of the Quran and Hadith, laid down for the Ummah solutions to all possible problems until the Day of Resurrection, and their principles. From these, if people find nothing directly in the Quran and Hadith, they will be able to solve problems in the light of the principles of the madhhab, subhanallah!

For this reason, an ordinary reader should never act on the literal meaning of the Quran and Hadith. Rather, they must return to the explanation and analysis of the jurists and act accordingly.

1.

On this, the imam of Hadith Sufyan ibn Uyaynah (RH) says -

الحديث مضلة إلا للفقهاء

Translation -

"Following hadith (according to one's own understanding) by anyone other than the jurists is a cause of confusion and misguidance."

Source - Khutbat al-Kitab al-Mu'ammal - Abu Shama 1/151.

2.

Imam al-Shafi'i (RH) is a famous jurist and mujtahid imam. Once, addressing some muhaddiths, he said -

أنتم الصيادلة ونحن الأطباء

Translation -

You are the pharmacists and we are the doctors. That is, a muhaddith will just determine the grade of a hadith, and the jurists give the details of rulings in the light of the hadith.

Source - Siyar A'lam an-Nubala 10/23.

3.

Imam al-Tirmidhi (RH), in a discussion about washing the deceased, says -

وكذلك قال الفقهاء وهم أعلم بمعاني الحديث،

Translation -

"The honoured jurists have said so. And in the meaning of hadith, the jurists are more knowledgeable."

Source - Sunan al-Tirmidhi (990)

Honoured reader,

From the above three accounts it is clearly understood that, to uncover the meaning of hadith, one must turn to the jurists and act on their explanation and analysis.

An ordinary person cannot read hadith directly and act accordingly. Rather, they must certainly, certainly turn to the discussions of the jurists. This is proven from the lives of the Salaf.

1.

Abdullah ibn Wahb (RH) says -

نظر مالك إلى العطاف بن خالد، فقال مالك: بلغني أنكم تأخذون من هذا! فقلت: بلى. فقال: ما كنا نأخذ إلا من الفقهاء.

Translation -

"Imam Malik (RH), addressing Attaf ibn Khalid (RH), said: I have learned that you follow hadith (directly)?

He replied: Yes! Imam Malik (RH) then said: We follow hadith only according to the explanation of the honoured jurists (RH)!"

Source - Tartib al-Madarik 1/139

2.

The Amir al-Mu'minin in Hadith, Abu az-Zinad Abdullah ibn Dhakwan (RH), says -

إن كنا لنلتقط السنن من أهل الفقه والثقة ونتعلمها شبيها بتعلمنا آيَ القرآن.

Translation -

"We used to take hadith from jurists and trustworthy people. And we learned hadith from the jurists the way one learns verses of the Quran."

Source - Jami' Bayan al-'Ilm 2/98

3.

About the imam of Hadith Waki' ibn al-Jarrah (RH), Yahya ibn Ma'in (RH) says -

يفتي بقول أبي حنيفة

Translation -

"He used to give fatwas according to the view of Imam Abu Hanifa (RH)."

Source - Akhbar Abi Hanifa wa Ashabuhu - Qadi al-Saymari p.155,

4.

The renowned Hafiz of Hadith, Imam Yahya ibn Sa'id al-Qattan (RH), says -

لا نكذب الله، ما سمعنا أحسن من رأي أبي حنيفة، وقد أخذنا بأكثر أقواله.

Translation -

"By Allah, I am not lying: I have not seen anyone with a better opinion than Abu Hanifa. We take most of his opinions."

Source - Tarikh Baghdad 15/473,

5.

About him, his own student Yahya ibn Ma'in (RH) says,

كان يفتي أيضا بقول أبي حنيفة.

Translation -

"He too used to give fatwas according to Abu Hanifa's view."

Source - Akhbar Abi Hanifa wa Ashabuhu - Qadi al-Saymari p.155

6.

Yahya ibn Ma'in (RH) (233 AH) says -

القراءة عندي قراءة حمزة، والفقه فقه أبي حنيفة، وعلى هذا أدركت الناس.

Translation -

"I take the qira'ah according to the method of Hamza (RH) and the fiqh of Abu Hanifa. And I have seen people doing the same."

Source - Akhbar Abi Hanifa wa Ashabuhu - Qadi al-Saymari p.87, Tarikh Baghdad 15/473

7.

The Amir al-Mu'minin in Hadith, Imam Sufyan al-Thawri (RH). About him Imam Abu Yusuf (RH) says,

سفيان الثوري أكثر متابعة لأبي حنيفة.

Translation -

"Sufyan al-Thawri (RH) agrees with Abu Hanifa in most cases."

Source - Fada'il Abi Hanifa - Ibn Abi al-Awwam p.105

8.

Imam Ali ibn al-Madini (RH) (234 AH) says,

سفيان الثوري كان يذهب ويفتي بفتواهم.

Translation -

"Sufyan al-Thawri (RH) acts and gives fatwas according to the view of the followers of Abu Hanifa (RA)."

Source - al-Jarh wa at-Ta'dil 1/58

Subhanallahil 'Aliyyil 'Azim!

I have presented to you some words and practices of trustworthy and famous narrators of the science of Hadith. From these, several things become clear -

1. Hadith cannot be understood without fiqh

2. The explanation of hadith must be taken from a mufti

3. The muhaddiths followed fiqh

4. Many great and trustworthy narrators of hadith were Hanafi followers.

5. Although they were muhaddiths, they followed a madhhab.

Final word,

I have quoted some of the words of those narrators through whom you and I received hadith, on matters of fiqh, madhhab and so on. Now what to think is entirely up to you!

Barakallahu feekum!