Chapter One · The Madhhab

What Is the Ruling on the Madhhab?

What is the ruling on the madhhab?

The unanimous answer to such a question is – for one who is not a mujtahid in matters of the Sharia, following a madhhab is wajib. Note: a mujtahid is one who can derive rulings by himself on matters that are not conclusively established in the Quran and Hadith, or one who has knowledge of all matters of the Sharia.

What is following a madhhab? First we must know that those who are mukallaf (accountable) under the Sharia are divided into two classes –

1. Those who, through their own knowledge and by the standard of the Quran and Hadith, have attained scholarship in the Sharia and have the ability to research / exercise ijtihad on unclear / unresolved matters.

2. Those who have not reached the above level, that is, the quality of ijtihad, will proceed as students / followers of some mujtahid imam, or as muqallid.

Some religious brothers say that one cannot follow a madhhab, because there is no direct instruction in the Quran and Hadith to follow a madhhab. There is no emphasis on following a madhhab!

Fine! Although learned and wise scholars have tried to explain with much interpretation and analysis, many religious brothers claim that since there is no direct instruction in the Quran and Hadith, one cannot follow a madhhab. And the dispute has remained at that.

In support of the answer "following a madhhab is wajib", although many indirect proofs are established from the Quran and Hadith, some of our brothers are not satisfied. Many of them claim that fard/wajib must either be laid down by Allah or by the Messenger ﷺ!

What a strange thing!

They will not follow any command or prohibition outside the Quran and Hadith. But the question remains: on matters where a command or prohibition has not come or been mentioned directly in the Quran and Hadith (for example, many contemporary issues), what will their position be?

Among them, let me mention one issue.

What is the status of learning the Arabic language?

Without doubt, everyone, madhhabi and non-madhhabi alike, says it is wajib. What is the reason? Or what is the evidence?

Anyway, without answering, I will quote the evidence that Ibn Taymiyyah (RA) presents in favour of "learning the Arabic language is wajib" –

'In the view of Shaykh Ibn Taymiyyah (RA), learning the Arabic language is wajib. In discussing the evidence he says that, in light of the Hadith, acquiring religious knowledge is fard upon every Muslim man and woman. And since religious knowledge is not possible without learning the Arabic language, learning Arabic is also fard, or according to another view, wajib.' Because there is a usul, or principle –

مالا يتم الواجب إلا به فهو واجب

That is, whatever an obligation cannot be completed without also becomes obligatory.

That is, since acquiring religious education is not possible without learning the Arabic language, learning the Arabic language is also wajib. Source – Introduction, Rawdat an-Nazir wa Jannat al-Munazir, 15

and اقتضاء الصراط المستقيم و 14 ص

From the evidence of Ibn Taymiyyah (RA) we clearly understood two things -

1. Learning the Arabic language is wajib. This is not stated directly in the Quran and Hadith. But it is wajib in light of qiyas (analogical reasoning).

2. Something can be wajib even without being stated in the Quran and Hadith. For example, learning the Arabic language.

Now let us come to the main discussion -

I said at the outset that although there are countless explanations from the Quran and Hadith in support of the answer "following a madhhab is wajib", they are not clear to many. So I want to explain this matter in the light of that same usul, that principle, in the light of which learning Arabic was established as wajib, even though it did not come directly in the Quran and Hadith.

We say -

Following one of the well-known four madhhabs is wajib. Because,

1 – the apparent conflict of one verse of the Quran with another,

2 – naskh in the Quran (abrogation of a ruling),

3 – the apparent ta'arud, or contradiction, between Quran and Hadith,

4 - determining authentic / weak hadith,

5 - the lack of clarity about solutions to all possible issues, or those not mentioned in the Quran and Hadith.

Apart from the above matters, there are countless other reasons why an ordinary person can never, on their own, directly derive or discover rulings (istinbat) from the Quran and Hadith and act on them. For that, they need to follow some well-ordered path (madhhab) or set of rules, in the light of which they will act or worship in accordance with the authentic Sunnah.

And since it is difficult or impossible for an ordinary Muslim to act directly from the Quran and Hadith, in that case one must follow some well-ordered view or path. And that is called following a madhhab, or following any recognised opinion.

Therefore, since because of one's own inability or weakness in ijtihad one must take the help of a madhhab in acting on the authentic Sunnah, we can say that just as acting on the authentic Sunnah is wajib, so is taking the path of a madhhab. Because, in light of reality, it can be said -

To act on the pure and absolute authentic Sunnah, you must accept some masalak (school) of the madhhab. Because without it you cannot reach a sound conclusion on any matter. Just as there is a usul, a principle, of the Sharia -

ما لا يتم الواجب إلا به فهو واجب

That is, whatever an obligation cannot be completed without also becomes obligatory.

That is, since an ordinary Muslim cannot act in accordance with the authentic Sunnah without a madhhab, just as acting on the authentic Sunnah is wajib, so too, in special need, following a madhhab is sometimes wajib.

Because Almighty Allah says clearly in the Holy Quran –

فَأَسْأَلُوا أَهْلَ الذِّكْرِ إِنْ كُنْتُمْ لَا تَعْلَمُونَ

That is, 'If you do not know, then ask the people of knowledge.' - Surah an-Nahl: verse 43.

And we are very ordinary people. Our Salaf followed the madhhab. In fact, they were muhaddiths, muftis and mufassirs.

Shaykh Salih al-Fawzan (may Allah preserve him), a renowned mufti and eminent scholar of Saudi Arabia, says -

"The great imams of Hadith were also followers of a madhhab. By way of example the Shaykh says -

1. Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah (RH) and Ibn al-Qayyim (RH) were Hanbali followers.

2. Imam al-Nawawi (RH) and Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani (RH) were Shafi'i followers.

3. Imam al-Tahawi (RH) was a Hanafi follower.

4. Imam Ibn Abd al-Barr (RH) was a follower of the Maliki madhhab.

Then the Shaykh says -

"Being a follower of any one of the four madhhabs is not misguidance for which one should be rebuked. Rather, if someone who does not have the qualification of a mutlaq mujtahid goes outside the words of the accepted jurists, then he will be regarded as misguided and a separatist."

Source - the Shaykh's book 'I'anat al-Mustafid bi-Sharh Kitab at-Tawhid', page 12.

Subhanallah!

From the words of the Shaykh (may Allah preserve him), several things became clear to us -

1. Following any one madhhab is not blameworthy

2. The imams of Hadith also followed a madhhab

3. In the eyes of Arab scholars, following a madhhab is permissible

4. One who follows a madhhab must in no way be called misguided or not correct.

Hayyakumullahu jami'an