Chapter One · The Madhhab

Why Are There Four Madhhabs?

That is a long story!

Why should there be four madhhabs? There were other madhhabs in history too, so why must we follow only these four? The four madhhabs came and divided Islam into four. Because of the differences between the madhhabs, Islam fell. Baghdad fell. Do you hear questions like these?

Yes! Perhaps many of you are already caught in the web of this question. Many may have faced the question and been left speechless for lack of a good answer. So I thought I should write something on the subject. Allah is the Granter of success!

Jazakumullahu khayran!

To make the matter clear, I am dividing the piece into two questions. This will make it easier for you to understand, insha Allah!

1. Why did the madhhab come?

2. Why four madhhabs out of many?

The first question -

Why a madhhab?

Answer -

We know that the ahkam of the Sharia, that is, its rulings and prohibitions, are of two kinds -

1. Clear ahkam

2. Unclear ahkam

On all those matters of the Sharia that are completely clear, there is no madhhab dispute. In other words, there is no madhhab dispute on the fundamentals of Islam. For example: the ruling on prayer is fard, the ruling on fasting is fard, and so on.

There are some matters of the Sharia that come unclear or hard to understand in the Quran and Hadith. In other words, differences have arisen because of unclarity in the furu', the branch issues of the Sharia.

On those furu', the branch matters of the Sharia, where unclarity has come, the greatest imams of the era of Islam exercised research by their own ability. And since the results of that research were multiple, madhhabs, or multiple schools of thought, came about.

For example: Allah the Exalted says in the Holy Quran, in Surah al-Baqarah verse 229 -

والمطلقات يتربصن بانفسهن ثلاثة قروء

In that verse, Allah the Exalted describes the iddah of divorced women. But the word 'quru'' in the verse is unclear. Whether this word 'quru'' means menstruation (hayd) or the period of purity (tuhr) is not clear. For this reason, the imams of the madhhabs researched and reached a result. And the difference in these results is what is called the madhhab.

In short: briefly, we learned two things -

1. There is no disagreement among the imams of the madhhabs on any fundamental matter of the Sharia. Rather, differences exist on the furu', that is, branch matters.

2. Madhhabs were not made to explain any clear matter of the Sharia. Rather, the madhhab, or difference of opinion, came to explain unclear and hard-to-understand matters.

3 – Multiple madhhabs came as the multiple results of research on unclear matters.

The second question -

Why did four madhhabs come out of many madhhabs?

Answer -

It is an eternal truth that in the era after the Companions and the major (kibar) Tabi'in, madhhabs were devised from the research of many mujtahid imams, or they became known as imams. The names of more than a hundred such mujtahid imams are found, who by their own ability, through ijtihad, gave solutions to many unclear and hard-to-understand matters of the Sharia. But later their views were not recognised as madhhabs.

There are many reasons for this. But I mention here a few fundamental ones -

1. A madhhab should be recognised only when it has given solutions to all possible problems of Islam, from beginning to end. But in no madhhab other than the four did all matters come out in full. As a result, only the well-known four madhhabs gained recognition in history. No other madhhab gained recognition.

2. What is most essential for a madhhab is having usul, principles. Because, to give a solution to any new matter in the future, usul, or principles, are needed. We see that no imam or madhhab other than the four has any principles. For this reason no madhhab other than the four gained recognition.

3. The madhhabs did not reach us through any information technology. Rather, the imams of the madhhabs exercised ijtihad. Muslim scholars preserved their research in every era. As a result these four madhhabs reached us in good form. No other madhhab reached us in that way. As a result no madhhab other than the four gained recognition.

4. The imams of the four recognised madhhabs of Islam had thousands of students, who worked to spread and propagate the madhhab. The madhhabs also received state recognition. In the Abbasid era, judgments were carried out according to the Hanafi madhhab. Other madhhabs did not receive that, which is why no madhhab other than the four gained recognition.

5. The books of the four recognised madhhabs reached us independently in the way that the books of no other madhhab did. So no madhhab other than the four gained recognition as one to be followed on its own.

In short, there is much more to say. But the most serious real point is that this is Allah the Exalted's own will, placed upon the Ummah as a blessing. Otherwise, it would not be at all natural for knowledge from thirteen hundred years ago to remain intact with us until now. Without the grace of Allah the Exalted, these madhhabs would have been wiped from the world long ago. But Allah the Exalted has raised up people in every era who held the review of the madhhab close to their hearts, and so it has reached us. This did not happen in the case of any other madhhab or school of thought besides the four.

And the scholars and ulama have ijma' on these four madhhabs. Ibn Nujaym al-Misri (970) (RH) says –

"Because of the firm establishment, spread and larger number of followers of the four madhhabs, there is ijma' not to act on anything contrary to these four madhhabs."

Source – al-Ashbah wa an-Nazair, 92

One brother once asked a question like this: what is the proof that all four madhhabs are right, or that following any one of them is right?

___

A terrifying question! I was at a loss. What could I say? After a muddle of thoughts, I said -

Dear brother,

See - no false path can last long. After every falsehood Allah brings the truth, and as soon as the truth comes, falsehood is defeated!

Almighty Allah says in Surah Bani Israel in the Holy Quran -

جَاءَ الْحَقُّ وَزَهَقَ الْبَاطِلُ

Translation -

Truth has come, and falsehood has vanished. Bani Israel 81

Dear brother,

The madhhab began its journey twelve hundred (1300) years ago. In every era Allah the Exalted has sent some special people, who carried the understanding of this knowledge. As a result, this madhhab has reached us!

If the madhhab were false, it should have vanished at some point in these long thirteen hundred years. But Allah the Exalted, by His special grace, has kept this madhhab exalted. In every era He has raised up mujtahid scholars, who kept the knowledge of this madhhab intact for Islam. In every era He has raised up people who followed this madhhab.

I also said,

My honoured brother, if this madhhab were false, then by Allah the Exalted's promise, another truth would have come by now and wiped it out. But through the ages Allah the Exalted has protected it. In every era, rather, falsehood has come and attacked the madhhab. Allah the Exalted has driven falsehood away and kept the madhhab honoured and dignified among the Ummah.

Lakal hamdu ya Allah!

From this it is proven that the madhhab can never be false, and that falsehood can never remain so long among the Ummah with the people of truth. I can say, insha Allah, thumma insha Allah - the madhhab is established as truth!

Finally I said a few more words to that brother with a heartfelt ache -

The imams of the four madhhabs probably did not know in their lifetimes that Allah the Exalted would accept them in this way across all eras and worldwide. May Allah the Exalted have mercy on Imam Malik (rahimahullah); he says – (heard as his saying)

'Whatever work of the religion is done solely for the pleasure of Allah the Exalted will remain (for the benefit of people until the Day of Judgment); and whatever is done for another purpose will be lost in the womb of time.'

ما کان لله يبقي، وما كان لغير الله يزول.ويدل عليه عموم قوله تعالي: فَأَمَّا الزَّبَدُ فَيَذْهَبُ جُفَاءً ۖ وَأَمَّا مَا يَنفَعُ النَّاسَ فَيَمْكُثُ فِي الْأَرْضِ

Translation -

Whatever work of the religion is done solely for the pleasure of Allah the Exalted will remain (for the benefit of people until the Day of Judgment); and whatever is done for another purpose will be lost in the womb of time.'

Then, as evidence, Imam Malik (RH) recited a verse of Surah ar-Ra'd of the Holy Quran, whose Bengali translation is -

"Thus Allah presents the parable of truth and falsehood. As for the foam, it is cast away; and as for that which benefits the people, it remains on the earth. Thus Allah presents parables." Bani Israel 81

The universal appeal and acceptance of the four madhhabs, and their spread, is a special mercy from Allah the Exalted, insha Allah. For those who have become desperate to prove false this accepted service of the mujtahids, built around the living example of the Companions, there is nothing to do but to feel sorrow and make du'a for them.

I was saying these words in one go, with a heartfelt ache, and the brother who had asked listened with great humility, his head bowed. When I finished, he raised his head a little and said –

Alhamdulillah,

I too said aloud – Alhamdulillah!

Ahsanallahu ilaykum!