Chapter One · The Madhhab

What Is the Ruling on Following One Specific Madhhab?

Can one follow one specific madhhab? Many have a hidden question about this, and it is very necessary to know it. So on this subject I will try to present the fatwas of earlier scholars, insha Allah!

It is universally accepted that in the fundamental and clear rulings of the Sharia and in matters of creed, there is no need for taqlid, or following, any imam. But in branch rulings, especially those on which there is disagreement or unclarity, there is no problem in following one specific madhhab.

Let us learn the comments of earlier Salaf on the recognition of the four madhhabs and on following one madhhab -

1. Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah (RH) (d. 728 AH), asked whether the madhhab of any mujtahid other than the four madhhabs may be followed, says in reply,

الاجماع اليوم قدانعقد على خلاف هذا القول.

Meaning: Contrary to this (on not following the madhhab of any mujtahid other than the four madhhabs) ijma' has been established today. (Fatawa Ibn Taymiyyah 20/584)

From the statement of Allama Ibn Taymiyyah (RH) it is proven that, by the agreement of the Ummah, at present only the madhhabs of the four imams are to be followed.

2. The renowned hadith researcher and analyst Imam al-Dhahabi (RH) (d. 748 AH) says,

فيمتنع تقليد غير الاربعة في القضاء والافتاء لان المذاهب الاربعة انتشرت تحررت.

Meaning: In fatwas on rulings and issues and in court judgments, taqlid and following anyone other than the four imams is prohibited. Because these four madhhabs have spread across the world and have been compiled in book form. (Fayd al-Qadir 1/269 and 288)

3. The historian Allama Ibn Khaldun (RH) (d. 808 AH) wrote in his world-famous book Tarikh Ibn Khaldun:

وقد صار اهل الاسلام اليوم على تقليد هولاء الائمة الاربعة.

Meaning: In this age the followers of Islam have chosen one of these four imams for taqlid (following). (Tarikh Ibn Khaldun 1/479)

4. The distinguished jurist Allama Ibn Nujaym (RH) (d. 970 AH) says,

وماخالف الائمة الاربعة فهو مخالف للاجماع.

Meaning: Any madhhab or opinion that is contrary to the four imams will be considered contrary to the ijma', the unanimous decision, of the Muslim Ummah. (al-Ashbah-169)

5. The famous jurist of the Indian subcontinent and specialist in the principles of fiqh, Shaykh Ahmad Mulla Jiyun (RH), writes in his book Tafsir al-Ahmadiyyah:

قد وقع الاجماع على ان الاتباع انما يجوز للاربع ...وكذا لايجوز لاتباع لمن حدث مجتهدا مخالفا لهم.

Meaning: Only the taqlid of the four imams is valid; ijma' has been established on this. Likewise, following any new mujtahid contrary to them will not be valid. (Tafsir al-Ahmadiyyah p: 346)

6. Hadrat Shah Waliullah Muhaddith al-Dehlawi (RH) (d. 1176 AH) says,

ان المذاهب الاربعة المدونة المحررة قد اجتمعت الامة اومن يعتد به منها على جواز تقليدها الى يومنا هذا.

Meaning: To this day, the agreement of the Muslim Ummah, that is, of the notable people of the Ummah, has been established on the permissibility of following these four compiled and codified madhhabs. (Hujjatullah al-Balighah 1/286)

Friends! Why taqlid of all the imams at once, or following different people on different matters, is not valid even though they are correct and acceptable: we have discussed this earlier in connection with taqlid shakhsi, or taqlid of a particular individual. Along with that, know this too: just as ijma' of the Ummah has been established that the correct and acceptable madhhabs are limited to the four madhhabs, so too in following, there is the view of the scholars that it is valid for a person to adopt only any one of the four madhhabs, and invalid to adopt several madhhabs.

Because following several madhhabs at once on contradictory decisions is impossible in practice, and following whichever madhhab one feels like at the time, according to one's inclination, is also against reason and logic. Because for a person who has the nafs al-ammarah, the evil-commanding self, the ally of Satan, that would be a tool of worshipping desire. This will become clearer through the following various statements, insha Allah.

1. Allama Ibn Taymiyyah (RH) says,

فيكونون في وقت يقلدون من يفسده وفي وقت يقلدون من يصححه بحسب الغرض والهوى ومثل هذا لايجوز باتفاق الائمة ونظير هذا ان يعتقد الرجل ثبوت شفعة الجوار اذا كان طالبا لها ويعتقد عدم الثبوت اذا كان مشتريا فان هذا لايجوز بالاجماع...لان ذالك يفتح باب التلاعب بالدين وفتح للذريعة الى ان يكون التحليل والتحريم بحسب الاهواء.

Meaning: If it suits their interest and desire, they follow the imam who gives a fatwa that the matter is impermissible according to their interest. And when it goes against their interest, the very same people follow an imam who gives a fatwa that the matter is permissible. Such unbridled slavery to desire is impermissible and unlawful according to all the imams. An example of this kind of matter is: when one is a neighbour and a claimant, saying that the 'right of pre-emption in purchase' is valid on the basis of being a neighbour, but when one is the buyer, saying it is invalid for the neighbour. Seeking out, on every matter, the madhhab that suits one's interest and acting accordingly is not lawful by ijma', the agreement of all. Because it opens the way to playing with the religion and opens the way to determining halal and haram according to one's own whims. (Fatawa Ibn Taymiyyah 32/100-101)

2. The renowned jurist and muhaddith of the present world, Allama Mufti Taqi Usmani (may Allah preserve him), has expressed the Ummah's agreement on following one specific imam like this,

فلو ابيح لكل احد ان ينتقى من هذه الاقوال ماشاء متى شاء لادى ذلك الى اتباع الهوى دون الشريعة الغراء وبالتالي فان كل واحد من هذه المذاهب له نظام خاص يعمل في اطاره بحيث ان كثيرا من مسائله مرتبط بعضها ببعض فلو اخذ منه حكما وترك حكما اخر يرتبط به لاختل ذالك النظام وحدثت حاله من التلفيق لايقول بصحتها احد...ومن هنا دعت الحاجة الى التمذهب بمذهب معين.

Meaning: If everyone were permitted to pick whatever opinions they like from these views whenever they like, it would only open the way to following desire, not the pure following of the Sharia....

Second: each of the madhhabs has its own principles, method of practice and system on the basis of which practice takes place there. As a result, many rulings are seen to be organically linked with one another. So if one ruling is taken and another ruling connected to it is discarded, the principles and order of the madhhab will be disrupted and a path to following desire will be created, which is called talfiq in technical terms. No one at all says it is valid....And for this very reason the necessity of following a specific madhhab has arisen. (Usul al-Ifta p: 63-64)

3. Allama al-Nawawi (RH) (d. 676 AH), author of the famous book Riyad as-Salihin, says,

انه لو جاز اتباع اي مذهب شاء لافضى الى ان يلتقط رخص المذاهب متبعا هواه ويتخير بين التحليل والتحريم والوجوب والجواز وذالك يؤدي الى انحلال ربقة التكليف..فعلى هذا يلزمه ان يجتهد في اختيار مذهب يقلده على التعيين.

Meaning: If it were permissible to follow any madhhab freely according to one's whims, it would push people, driven by desire, to snatch up the easy, convenient and favourable matters of the madhhabs, and to take whatever decisions the heart prefers on matters of haram and halal, and of the required and the permissible. And this attitude would release the reins of shar'i obligation. So it is essential to strive sincerely in choosing a specific madhhab for the purpose of following. (al-Majmu' Sharh al-Muhadhdhab. Introduction 1/120-121

Hafiz of Hadith Allama al-Dhahabi (RH) says,

وعلى غير المجتهد ان يقلد مذهبا معينا.

Meaning: For a ghayr mujtahid, that is, a person ignorant of, inexperienced in, or of little experience in the Quran, Hadith and the principles of the Sharia, it is indispensable to act by following the madhhab of a specific imam. (Fayd al-Qadir 1/269)

5. Hadrat Shah Waliullah Muhaddith al-Dehlawi (RH) says,

اعلم ان الناس كانوا في المائة الاولى والثانية غير مجتمعين على التقليد لمذهب واحد بعينه وبعد المائتين ظهر فيهم التمذهب للمجتهدين باعيانهم ...وعلى هذا ينبغي ان القياس وجوب التقليد لامام بعينه.

Meaning: In the first and second centuries AH the Muslims were not united on following the madhhab of any specific imam, that is, until then the need for it had not arisen. But after the second century the need arose to follow the madhhabs of specific mujtahids....So the taqlid, or following, of a specific imam being wajib is the very demand of reason and prudence. (al-Insaf p: 68-70)

Of the above five statements, the first two lay out the reality of following the madhhab of any one imam and the ijma' on it, and the later statements have strengthened it further. So at present there is no alternative for Muslims to following the madhhab of a specific imam.

And the ijma' of the scholars of the 4th century on following the madhhab of any one of the four imams being required is found in reliable books. For example-

al-Insaf-52, 57-59.

Madar-e-Haq-341.

Intisar al-Haqq bi-Jawab Miyar al-Haqq-153.

al-Muwafaqat-4/146

al-Majmu' Sharh al-Muhadhdhab-1/91

Rahimakumullah!