Does Following a Madhhab Mean Taqlid Shakhsi?
Is following a madhhab taqlid shakhsi, that is, following an individual? Is following a madhhab following the words of a person, or following the Quran and Hadith? There are quite a few misunderstandings about this. In this piece I will try to remove the errors, insha Allah!
First –
Is following any madhhab doing taqlid shakhsi? No, this is a mistaken idea. Many people think that following a madhhab means solely following the imam of that madhhab. In fact, this is merely a misunderstanding. There are three reasons –
1 – Following a madhhab means accepting all the mufta bihi opinions of that madhhab (the opinions on which the fatwa is given). And the mufta bihi opinion is not always that of the imam of the madhhab. Rather, it is sometimes that of other imams of the madhhab. A madhhab has several mujtahid imams, and the opinion of each of them is given preference on some ruling or other. So how does following a single imam remain?
2 – In every madhhab we see that the imam's students disagreed with the imam himself on the basis of evidence. And sometimes the fatwa is established on the students' opinions. So how does following a single imam remain?
3 – As days go by, various contemporary problems are discovered. The living great muftis give the Sharia solutions to these problems, and followers of the madhhab follow the fatwas of those muftis. So where in the madhhab does single following remain?
Second –
Does the Hanafi madhhab mean taqlid shakhsi, or following one person? In context I think a discussion of this matter is necessary. Because, as most people in our country are Hanafi followers, we often face this question.
Many have the mistaken idea that those who follow the Hanafi madhhab do taqlid of one person, namely Imam Abu Hanifa (RA).
This idea is not correct at all. At its beginning the Hanafi madhhab was formed from the coordination of forty mujtahid honoured jurists. Since then it has passed through a total of seven stages in sequence to reach us. At each stage the mujaddids, muhaqqiqs and mujtahid honoured jurists of the era made many changes and so on. They adopted the most authentic view closest to the Quran and Sunnah.
So the Hanafi madhhab does not mean only the madhhab of Imam Abu Hanifa. At the very beginning of the Hanafi madhhab, on countless rulings the view of Imam al-A'zam was set aside and a different view was adopted. Since then, the countless ijtihads, or views, of countless imams, including Imam Abu Yusuf, Imam Muhammad, Imam Zufar, Imam Abu al-Hasan al-Shaybani and Imam al-Tahawi (rahimahumullah), have entered the Hanafi madhhab. For this reason our madhhab came to be called the Hanafi madhhab rather than the Abu Hanifa madhhab. That is, it began with Imam Abu Hanifa (RA), but afterward the ijtihad and research of countless mujtahid jurists were blended in.
So those who say that Hanafis do taqlid shakhsi, or follow one person, are mistaken and make a false accusation. These statements have no basis. The Hanafi madhhab is essentially the name of the final harvest of the research of the greatest scholars in every era. It is not the name of any single opinion or research. In detail, we will discuss it in the chapter on the Hanafi madhhab, insha Allah!
To learn more in detail - read pages 6/7/8 of the book Manaqib al-Imam Abu Hanifa (RA). Read books, know history, and insha Allah all doubts and accusations will turn to dust.
Besides, if we look carefully we see that,
الفقه على المذاهب الأربعة
In this book, wherever the view of the Hanafi madhhab has come, on whatever ruling it has come, it is said there,
الحنفية قالوا
If it were the personal madhhab of Imam al-A'zam Abu Hanifa (RA), it would have been said,
قال أبي حنيفة النعمان بن ثابت رضي الله عنه.
Abu Hanifa Nu'man ibn Thabit (rahimahullah) said! That is, it should have been said in this way.
But we have seen that wherever the fatwa of the Hanafi madhhab has come, it has been said,
الحنفية قالوا
Since the word Hanafiyyah has been used here, this is not the personal view of Imam al-A'zam Abu Hanifa (RA). Rather, many faqihs and mujtahids are joined with him. For this reason the plural form has been used.
Now let us look at a few examples where, in the Hanafi madhhab, the fatwa is not on the view of Imam al-A'zam Abu Hanifa (RH) but on the view of his students.
In the Hanafi madhhab, fatwa on the view of Imam Abu Yusuf (RH)
1. In the view of Imam Abu Hanifa (RH) and Muhammad (RH), when a judge writes a letter to another judge for a ruling, the contents of the letter must be read out to the bearer, and only then must it be sealed in front of him and handed over. Otherwise, this letter will not be effective for completing the judicial work. On the other hand, in the view of Imam Abu Yusuf (RH), if the letter is simply written and sent to another judge without informing the bearer, judicial work can still be conducted by it. The fatwa is on this view. So here the view of Imam Abu Hanifa (RH) and Muhammad (RH) is not to be acted on.
Source - al-Hidayah-3/123-124
2. When a simple-minded witness comes to testify in the qadi's court, the judge cannot teach the witness the method of testimony. This is not permissible in the view of Imam Abu Hanifa (RH) and Muhammad (RH). But in the view of Imam Abu Yusuf (RH), teaching a person who does not understand is not only permissible but better. The fatwa is on this view.
Source - Fatawa Shami-8/53
Fatwa on the view of Imam Muhammad (RH)
1. In almost all rulings on the distribution of inheritance, that is, of the estate, the fatwa is on the statement of Imam Muhammad (RH).
2. In the view of Imam Abu Hanifa (RH), the water of wudu is impure. So if it touches the body, the clothes become impure. And Imam Muhammad (RH) says: the water of wudu is pure. But purity cannot be attained with it. The fatwa is on this view.
Fatwa on the view of Imam Zufar (RH)
1. A sick person who cannot pray standing may sit however he likes and pray, in the view of Imam Abu Hanifa (RH) and Abu Yusuf and Muhammad (RH). But in the view of Imam Zufar (RH), he must sit in the posture of tashahhud and pray. The fatwa is on this view. (Fatawa Shami-2/565)
2. In the view of the three imams, seeing the courtyard of a house forfeits the right of viewing at the time of purchase. But in the view of Imam Zufar (RH), seeing the courtyard of a house does not forfeit the right to see the inside. The fatwa of Hanafi fiqh is on this view. (Fatawa Shami-7/158)
In the Hanafi madhhab, quite a few such fatwas are seen where the fatwa of the madhhab is on the view of the imam's student. Therefore, to say that following a madhhab means taqlid shakhsi, or following all the views of a single individual, is unreasonable.
Hafizakumullah!