Can One Change Madhhab?
This matter is very important. Can one change madhhab or not? That is, if someone is of the Hanafi madhhab, can he become Maliki / Shafi'i or Hanbali?
On this matter there is excess in our country, and at the same time a lack of sufficient understanding of an important issue. If someone is Hanafi and wants to change to another madhhab, then no scholar, and especially no Hanafi, supports it. Rather, they scold him severely.
This is very sad! Such harshness on the madhhab is never desirable. The madhhab must be dealt with with wisdom and tolerance. Otherwise, fitna and mischief will never end.
Anyway, the straight answer to the question of whether one can change madhhab is –
Yes, one can change madhhab. That is, if you do not have itqan, or satisfaction, with your Hanafi madhhab, you may follow another madhhab. In this matter the Sharia does not forbid it, and neither do the usul of the four madhhabs.
Evidence –
The madhhab developed progressively through the students of each imam. When we read history we see countless students of the imams who left the madhhab of their own imam and adopted the madhhab of another imam.
Imam al-Sha'rani (RA) – narrates from Imam al-Qarafi (RA) on changing madhhab –
يجوز الانتقال من جميع المذاهب إلى بعضها بعضا
That is, every madhhab has permitted changing from one madhhab to another.
Source: – al-Mizan al-Kubra /39
Imam al-Suyuti (RA) has presented examples of several scholars, students of the honoured imams of the four madhhabs, who later changed the madhhab of their own imam –
1. Shaykh Abd al-Aziz al-Khaza'i (RH) first followed the Maliki madhhab. Later, when Imam al-Shafi'i (RA) came to Baghdad, he became a follower of the Shafi'i madhhab.
2. Ibrahim al-Baghdadi (RA) was first of the Hanafi madhhab. Later, when Imam al-Shafi'i (RA) came to Baghdad, he became an admirer of the Shafi'i madhhab.
3. Imam al-Tahawi (RA) was at first a famous imam and admirer of the Shafi'i madhhab. Later, when al-Tahawi (RA) received instruction in the Hanafi madhhab from his own maternal uncle Imam al-Muzani (RA), he left the Shafi'i madhhab and became an imam or follower of the Hanafi madhhab.
4. Likewise, Ibn Faris (RA), the author of the famous book al-Mujmal, was at first of the Shafi'i madhhab. Later, he became a follower of the Maliki madhhab.
Source – al-Mizan al-Kubra / 40
Dear brothers!
The madhhab is not something directly and clearly quoted from the Quran and Hadith. Rather, it is a great scholarly service by the honoured imams through ijtihad, and merely a well-arranged resolution of disputed or unseen issues. Its spread and growth took place through the students of the honoured imams.
Therefore, instead of giving evidence from the Quran and Hadith for whether one can change madhhab, I have presented the history of the students of the honoured imams, through whom the madhhab was established, changing madhhab. From it, it is clearly understood that there is no obstacle in the Sharia or in the usul of the madhhab to changing madhhab.
But, my dear brothers,
To those who repeatedly ask this question, whether one can change madhhab, I have two words –
Religious brother!
See – the madhhab has reached us through a huge religious service. Through the writing, reading and sermons of thousands of scholars, the Hanafi madhhab came to our subcontinent. So we have received this madhhab as a matter of course.
Although the above discussion proves the permissibility of changing madhhab, it does not mean that you will be saved merely by changing madhhab if you wish. Before changing madhhab you must certainly take note of the following matters –
In your country / district or area, for the madhhab you are about to follow –
(1) Is there any scholar or not?
(So that you can ask them when you get stuck)
(2) Is there any mufti or not?
(So that you can ask them for fatwas)
(3) Is there any madrasa / institution or not?
(So that you can study there if you want to learn)
(4) Are there any books / publications / fatwa collections or not?
(So that you can get them if you want to study on your own)
Dear religious brothers,
Before changing the madhhab of any honoured imam, verify whether the above four things are available around you. Otherwise, it can turn out contrary to the good. Because, in the examples given above of those who changed madhhab, think: they changed madhhab precisely when they gained the company of an imam of that madhhab. Besides, they were all roughly at the level of ijtihad.
Suppose,
You want to change from Hanafi to the Maliki madhhab. Then you must consider whether in our country the Maliki madhhab has –
1 – any scholar or not?
2 – any mufti or not?
3 – any institution or not?
4 – any fatwa book or not?
If you find them, then you may change to the Maliki madhhab without hesitation. Otherwise, the noble and beneficial course for you is to remain on the madhhab that is current in your country. The madhhab whose scholars / books and so on exist in your country. Jazakallahu khayran!
Fi amanillah!