Chapter One · The Madhhab

Can the Four Madhhabs Be Followed at the Same Time?

There are many brothers who follow khiyar fil-madhhab, that is, choice by whim: whichever madhhab they feel like at the time, they follow. That is, whenever a madhhab's ruling suits their own situation, they take the ruling of that madhhab.

According to the statements of some of them, they claim to follow the four madhhabs and say: whichever of the four madhhabs is stronger at the time, that one I will follow.

Again, many say - the four madhhabs are true. So what is the problem in following all four at once, or whichever I like? All four madhhabs are indeed true!

I myself have especially faced this question many times. To all who asked, I just said - the principles of each madhhab and the pattern of stating rulings differ. If you try to follow several madhhabs at once, you will often get into trouble with your practice, and sometimes it can even be the cause of your practice being invalidated.

In this piece I will try to explain exactly that: how following two madhhabs at once, or following convenient rulings, invalidates practice -

Suppose the discussion is about two different views of the Hanafi and Shafi'i madhhabs -

To begin with, let me mention two rulings -

1. Whether wudu is broken if blood comes out of someone's body ___ according to the Hanafi madhhab, wudu will be broken. According to the Shafi'i madhhab, wudu will not be broken.

2. If an adult man touches a non-mahram woman without a barrier, whether his wudu is broken ___ according to the Hanafi madhhab, wudu will not be broken. According to the Shafi'i madhhab, wudu will be broken.

Now suppose,

There is a convenience-seeking person who always wants to act on the easier and more favourable view from the four madhhabs. If on a winter day blood comes out of his body, then, for convenience, he takes the Shafi'i view and says ___ my wudu is not broken. In this case he will not follow the Hanafi madhhab, because if he takes the Hanafi view he will have to make wudu again on a winter day!

Right after, by forgetfulness or however it happened, he touches a non-mahram woman without a barrier. Now he thinks: is my wudu broken by this? He thinks and sees that according to the Hanafi madhhab, in this situation wudu is not broken. So he takes the Hanafi view and abandons the Shafi'i view. Because if he takes the Shafi'i view he will have to make wudu again.

The man took the Shafi'i view on the first ruling, the issue of bleeding, and the Hanafi view on the second ruling, the issue of touching a non-mahram woman. That is, on two separate rulings he took the convenient view from two different madhhabs. As a result he did not have to make wudu. Despite bleeding and touching a non-mahram woman, he prayed without making new wudu.

After praying, it occurred to him: I have prayed. But now let me ask two scholars - is my prayer valid?

1 - First he went to a mufti trained in the Hanafi madhhab, and described the above incident -

The mufti gave the fatwa - your prayer is not valid. Because when blood flows from the body, wudu is broken. Your wudu was broken before the prayer. But you did not make new wudu. So you prayed without wudu. And prayer without wudu is never valid.

Disappointed with the Hanafi mufti, he went to -

2 - a mufti trained in and learned in the Shafi'i madhhab. He described the above incident -

The Shafi'i mufti gave the fatwa - your prayer is not valid. Because you touched a non-mahram woman while in wudu. And this touch broke your wudu. But you did not make new wudu before the prayer. And prayer without wudu is never valid.

What a situation! In trying to follow both, in the view of neither was the prayer valid. Although this is an example, the end result of following several madhhabs at once is often almost like this.

Anyway, dear reader,

To present the discussed matter with its evidences would need a very long piece. So I tried to explain it very briefly. I hope you will not try to follow whichever madhhab is convenient or whichever you like at the time. If you follow a madhhab, adopt one madhhab on the basis of evidence. In the name of following a madhhab, do not invent another new path - khiyar fil-madhhab, or arbitrariness in the madhhab.

And the Salaf have issued a fatwa that following a madhhab by whim is haram. Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah (rahimahullah) says –

فيكونون في وقت يقلدون من يفسده وفي وقت يقلدون من يصححه بحسب الغرض والهوى ومثل هذا لايجوز باتفاق الائمة ونظير هذا ان يعتقد الرجل ثبوت شفعة الجوار اذا كان طالبا لها ويعتقد عدم الثبوت اذا كان مشتريا فان هذا لايجوز بالاجماع...لان ذالك يفتح باب التلاعب بالدين وفتح للذريعة الى ان يكون التحليل والتحريم بحسب الاهواء.

Meaning: If it suits their interest and desire, they follow the imam who gives a fatwa that the matter is impermissible according to their interest. And when it goes against their interest, the very same people follow an imam who gives a fatwa that the matter is permissible. Such unbridled slavery to desire is impermissible and unlawful according to all the imams. An example of this kind of matter is: when one is a neighbour and a claimant, saying that the 'right of pre-emption in purchase' is valid on the basis of being a neighbour, but when one is the buyer, saying it is invalid for the neighbour. Seeking out, on every matter, the madhhab that suits one's interest and acting accordingly is not lawful by ijma', the agreement of all. Because it opens the way to playing with the religion and opens the way to determining halal and haram according to one's own whims. (Fatawa Ibn Taymiyyah 32/100-101)

The practice of following one specific madhhab is proven from very early scholars and the mutaqaddimin. This discussion is not hidden from any people of knowledge.

Is that all? Depending on circumstances, and especially on the shaykh, there are accounts of many muhaddiths changing from one specific madhhab to another specific madhhab.

For example -

1. Imam al-Tahawi (RH) changed from the Shafi'i madhhab to the Hanafi madhhab.

2. Imam Ibn Daqiq (RH) changed from the Maliki madhhab to the Shafi'i madhhab.

3. Imam Abu Thawr (RH) changed from the Hanafi madhhab to the Shafi'i madhhab.

4. Imam Ibn Faris (RH) changed from the Shafi'i to the Maliki madhhab.

5. Imam Ibn ad-Dahhan (RH) changed from the Hanbali madhhab to the Hanafi madhhab.

6. Imam Abu Hayyan (RH) changed from the Zahiri madhhab to the Shafi'i madhhab.

Source - Fayd al-Qadir, 1/211

Imam al-Suyuti (RH), a famous figure of the Shafi'i madhhab, mentions in his famous book 'Jazil al-Mawahib fi Ikhtilaf al-Madhahib' the names of many Salaf who changed from other madhhabs to the Shafi'i madhhab. Likewise, Shaykh Zakariyya (RH) mentions in his outstanding book 'Lami' ad-Darari, Sharh of Bukhari' the names of many muhaddiths and imams who changed from other madhhabs to the Hanafi madhhab.

Source - al-I'timad fi Tawdih al-Iqtisad, 120

Following a specific madhhab that is on the path of truth is nothing blameworthy. Rather, it protects one from the desires of the nafs and from arbitrariness in religion. For this Shaykh Uthaymeen (RA) says -

'People are of three kinds in their connection to a madhhab. One: those who follow one specific madhhab on the belief that it is the closest to correctness in matters of disagreement....'

Source - Majmu' Fatawa wa Rasa'ilihi 26/285

May Allah the Exalted grant all of us the ability to walk the path of the Salaf – Ameen.