How Should One Read the Quran and Hadith?
Alhamdulillah, it brings great peace when I see that in our country countless young brothers, group after group, have begun walking the path of the religion as practising Muslims. This is a matter of great joy and hope for us! I pray that Allah the Exalted grant the young brothers of our country the ability to become even more practising Muslims - Ameen!
But sometimes one worrying thing is observed. Of those who begin the journey into practising Islam, most of the educated ones are becoming eager and interested in reading the Quran and Hadith on their own.
Behind this, perhaps, the contribution of a particular group is at work. They are instructing the youth: there is a Bengali Bukhari in the market. Buy it and study on your own! There is no need to go to a madrasa. No need to find a teacher. Knowledge is abundant on the internet. Learn from there. Islam is never imprisoned in any madrasa or confined to any shaykh!
From such encouraging talk, some of our young brothers buy a Bengali Bukhari from the market and start roughly a personal study. Although this is a good side in a partial view, in the broader thought it is not right at all. It can create obstacles on the path of the religion and open the way to misguidance.
Because acquiring knowledge of the Quran and Hadith is fard, and from whom you take it _ this is a part of the religion. There is no history that anyone ever acquired the knowledge of the religion correctly alone. So in today's piece I will discuss the necessity of a teacher / shaykh in acquiring the knowledge of the religion, insha Allah!
Why must one take instruction from a shaykh in acquiring the knowledge of the religion? Behind this I mention one logical reason and one evidence-based reason -
1. The logical reason -
We see that in history no muhaddith or religious scholar became a muhaddith / mufassir / mufti through his own study. They acquired the knowledge of the religion in the company of some shaykh.
For example -
√ The teacher of the Messenger was Allah Himself, subhanahu wa ta'ala. Through Jibril (AS) Allah the Exalted gave instruction and training to the Messenger ﷺ.
√ The teacher of the Companions was the Messenger ﷺ himself. The Companions used to come to the Messenger's circle of teaching. They asked directly, and in this way took instruction in the religion.
√ The Tabi'in acquired the knowledge of the religion directly from the Companions. From the era of the Tabi'in, separate lessons in the Quran, Hadith and fiqh began.
√ The honoured imams of the madhhabs and famous scholars took instruction from some shaykh. For example -
Imam Abu Hanifa took instruction from Alqama (RA)
Imam Malik (RA) took instruction from Hasan al-Basri
Imam al-Shafi'i (RA) took instruction from Muhammad
Imam Ahmad (RA) took instruction from Abu Yusuf
Imam al-Bukhari (RA) took instruction from Imam Ahmad
Imam Muslim (RA) took instruction from al-Bukhari
( They have thousands of teachers. I have drawn just one example here.)
In this way, the honoured servants of the religion of Islam who have passed through history acquired knowledge of the Quran/Hadith/fiqh from some shaykh. No one ever acquired knowledge sitting at home. Rather, to acquire religious knowledge or to find a shaykh, they crossed thousands of miles.
2. The evidence-based reason -
It is proven from various statements and narrations of the Salaf that acquiring the knowledge of the Quran and Hadith is fard. And learning from an ustadh and shaykh is itself a part of the religion. For example, Imam Ibn Sirin and Imam Malik (RA) say,
إن هذا العلم دين فانظروا عمّن تأخذون دينكم
" Surely this knowledge (of the Quran and Hadith) is a part of the religion. Look, from whom you are taking your religious knowledge "
Source: al-Kifayah, Khatib al-Baghdadi p. 121, 159.
From this, two things become clear -
1. Knowledge of the Quran and Hadith cannot be acquired from just anyone. Rather, religious knowledge may be acquired from the person who -
√ is skilled in the knowledge of the Quran and Hadith
√ is God-fearing and pious
√ acts according to his knowledge
√ abstains from lying / backbiting and the like.
2. Religious knowledge must be learned from some qualified shaykh. Not only these two; to this effect it is narrated from Salaf including Imam Ahmad and Yusuf that religious learning must be learned from some God-fearing, pious, learned and wise scholar.
This is the review of history. Now let us come to how Bukhari lessons are held in the Arab world, apart from Bangladesh. Since I live in Saudi Arabia, I speak from the firsthand experience here.
Naturally, because of language, we are behind them in the knowledge of the Quran and Hadith on the whole. The language of the Quran and Hadith is their mother tongue. So if they want, they can acquire the knowledge of the religion easily. If they want, they could sit at home and read alone and become very great muftis / muhaddiths / mufassirs.
But do you know the real truth?
The shaykhs of their country do not encourage them to sit at home, buy a Bukhari from the market and read alone. So the general monotheist public of Arabia either takes lessons in the Quran and Hadith academically, or receives personal instruction from some shaykh.
Let me mention one proof -
You who come for Umrah / Hajj will see that in the Haram of Makkah or Madinah or in various mosques, circles of lessons are being held. In these lessons the honoured shaykhs give lessons on various subjects, and the audience in front, young and old, listens with ears pricked. That is, those who have not studied academically do not learn the knowledge of the Quran and Hadith alone sitting at home but come to the Haram and learn from various shaykhs. Besides, in various corners of the Haram at various times one can see a shaykh and a student busy in deep study. That is, a seeker of religious knowledge is taking a lesson alone from the shaykh of his choice.
Let me tell a small example,
For the information of those who advise our practising Muslim brothers to buy a Bengali Bukhari and read alone, let me tell the brief story of the collection of his outstanding book "Sahih al-Bukhari" by Imam al-Bukhari (RA) himself -
Imam al-Bukhari (RA) himself, describing the number of his shaykhs / ustadhs, says -
كتبت عن ألف و ثمانين رجلا ليس فيهم إلا صاحب الحديث
" I have written hadith from one thousand and eighty shaykhs. All of whom were hadith specialists. "
Source: Siyar A'lam an-Nubala - 395
That was the number of his shaykhs. Now let us see how many his students were, or how many muhaddiths took hadith instruction from him -
Imam Muhammad ibn Yusuf al-Firabri (RA), discussing the number of Imam al-Bukhari's disciples, says -
سمع كتاب الصحيح لمحمد بن إسماعيل تسعون ألف رجل
That is, " ninety thousand people heard from him the outstanding book of Imam al-Bukhari (RA), "Kitab as-Sahih, or Sahih al-Bukhari". "
Think, the very Bukhari that is advised to be bought from the market and read alone, the honoured author, Imam al-Bukhari, gathered that same Bukhari from one thousand and eighty people, and from it about ninety thousand people took discipleship.
Now I will discuss the negative aspects of solitary study and the positive aspects of taking instruction from some shaykh -
The voids you will feel if you study alone -
1. You will remain deprived of a Sunnah and of the practice of the Salaf
2. You will get into trouble in determining the grade of hadith
3. You will get into a huge mess over the ta'arud (contradiction) within hadiths
4. You will get into a great problem for not knowing nasikh-mansukh
5. You will always suffer from satanic whispers
What you will benefit if you take instruction from a learned and wise shaykh -
1. A Sunnah will be acted upon
2. The path shown by the Salaf will be followed
3. You will be able to know what is sahih and da'if
4. You will be able to know the abrogating and abrogated verses and hadiths
5. You will be able to know the accompanying discussions of a hadith
6. You will be able to know which is preferred in conflicting hadiths
7. You will be able to know the rulings connected with a hadith
8. You will be able to acquire knowledge about various narrators
9. You will get the real dignity of a seeker of religious knowledge
10. You will be able to take your chain of religious learning all the way to the Messenger ﷺ himself.
Dear religious brothers,
That you are becoming interested in religious work and advancing in acquiring religious knowledge - this is great joyful news for us. We want this noble effort of yours to match the work of the Salaf. So my request to everyone is: instead of buying Bengali books from the market and studying alone, take lessons from some acceptable shaykh nearby according to your own preference. Or if time and opportunity do not permit, study alone, but at least try to read while following a religious mentor, even if distant, and get it verified. In this way your effort will find completeness, and you will get the dignity of a complete seeker of knowledge, insha Allah.