What Was the Madhhab of the Messenger and the Companions?
Subhanallah! How low hatred of the madhhab can bring a person, we understand through one or two such questions. There are many such brothers among us who sometimes ask - I will follow the madhhab; but whose madhhab did the Messenger follow? Whose madhhab did the Companions follow?
Yet any Muslim should know that the Messenger's madhhab was revelation. He said nothing outside revelation, to which the Quran itself testifies. And the Companions' madhhab? This is another confusing question! They had the Messenger ﷺ. Wherever necessary they asked the Messenger directly and learned. And in the Messenger's absence the junior Companions asked and learned from the senior Companions. Sometimes the senior Companions exercised ijtihad themselves. Examples of all this are also in Bukhari. Even so, why our brothers ask such questions is beyond my understanding.
Anyway, I present below the summary of a debate on some such matters, which will help you understand the main subject a little further, insha Allah.
At one point in the debate he said -
What was the Messenger's madhhab?
I said -
The Messenger's madhhab was revelation.
He said again -
Then what was the Companions' madhhab?
I said -
The Companions' madhhab was the Messenger ﷺ himself.
He now said -
Then why is our madhhab different?
I said -
Because just as revelation will not come to us, so too there will be no chance to ask the Messenger ﷺ directly as the Companions did.
He said again -
What if revelation is not sent down, what if we do not have the Messenger -- the Quran and Hadith are there?
I said -
Do you have the ability to state rulings and issues directly from the Quran and Hadith, that is, the ability of ijtihad? Then the madhhab is not for you. I do not have this ability at all, so I follow the madhhab of the jurists. By studying and knowing their ijtihad, I act correctly on the Quran and Sunnah.
At last - he turned his face away from me.
And I - engaged in prayer to Allah for him: O Allah! Grant correct understanding to me and to this brother of mine.
Later -
The brother, thinking about something, came back to the inbox and said - Actually, brother, the la-madhhab came and created fitnah. They created whispers (waswasa) in practice. I now want to be saved from mental illness.
I said -
Dear brother! I said that already. It is not possible for me to exercise ijtihad. So I follow the madhhab, and acting on the Sunnah of the Messenger keeping their views in front of me. As a result I have no waswasa in my practice. I have no mental illness in my brain, alhamdulillah. And this was essentially the teaching of the madhhab: so that, in following the correct guidance of the Quran and Hadith, people do not flounder in a boundless sea or suffer from the disease of waswasa. For that reason the greatest imams of the era left a stream of peace for the Ummah. And that is - a well-ordered and waswasa-free view and path of the Sharia, known as the madhhab.
A small piece of happy news came from the other side -
Brother! Then from today I too have taken the same path as you!
Alhamdulillah - ala kulli hal