Chapter Four · Miscellaneous

How Did the Companions Issue Fatwas?

Let us learn at a glance how the honoured Companions (RA) used to issue fatwas.

Once a man asked Ibn Umar (RA) about a ruling. Ibn Umar (RA), hearing the ruling, kept his head bowed and did not give the questioner any answer. The questioner supposed that Ibn Umar (RA) perhaps had not heard his question.

So the man said to Ibn Umar (RA):

May Allah have mercy on you, O Ibn Umar, have you not heard my question?

Ibn Umar (RA) said -

Certainly, I heard! But you think that Allah the Exalted will not ask us about the matter on which you ask us!

Ibn Umar (RA) further said -

Leave the matter to us. We will think deeply about the matter. If we have a suitable answer, we will tell you. And if we find no answer, we will say we have no knowledge of this matter. Source - طبقات ابن سعد ط العلمية (4/126)

Allahu Akbar!

Now think how very cautious Ibn Umar (RA), a Companion of exalted rank, was about fatwas. The honoured Companions (RA) never considered themselves free of liability by giving a fatwa. They feared Allah in giving fatwas. They were careful about Allah's questioning. They never gave a fatwa without being fully and firmly sure.

Note that a fatwa does not mean simply saying it whenever there is evidence from the Quran and Hadith. Rather, a fatwa is giving a solution in the light of the Quran, Hadith and the principles of fatwa, considering the situation of the questioner, the environment, the time and so on.

Ibn Jama'ah (rahimahullah) says –

Most of the Companions of the Messenger ﷺ gave fatwas very rarely. There are many Companions of whose lifetimes only one or two fatwas are known. Most Companions abstained from giving fatwas out of caution.

Source - تذكرة السامع والمتكلم ص 23