Chapter Three · The Hanafi Madhhab

Is the Hanafi Madhhab Against Authentic Hadith?

A very common question is that the Hanafi madhhab often gives views contrary to authentic hadith. This is a common question among ordinary people. I consider it important to shed some light on this matter!

Allah is the Granter of success!

See, on many rulings we see that the Hanafi madhhab has some evidences that are apparently contrary to authentic hadith. It may seem to you that,

1. The Hanafi madhhab is against authentic hadith

2. The Hanafi madhhab leaves the authentic and follows the da'if hadith

3. The authentic hadith did not reach the Hanafi madhhab

Various questions like these may buzz in your head. But dear brother, have you ever investigated and examined why the Hanafi madhhab does not accept an authentic hadith as soon as it finds it? Or learned it from some learned person? On such a subtle matter I will present some important words to you in this piece.

Suppose,

As an illustration, let us take a hadith –

أيما امرأة نكحت بغير إذن وليها فنكاحها باطل

That is, if a woman marries without the permission of her guardian, her marriage will be considered void.

This hadith has been accepted by many muhaddiths including Imam Abu Dawud, Tirmidhi and Ibn Majah, and the grade of the hadith is of the hasan level. In order, 2/566, 3/407, 1/605

On the apparent view, this is a hadith fit for practice. Anyone, reading it plainly, will understand that if a woman marries without a guardian, that marriage is void.

But this hadith was not accepted by Imam al-A'zam Abu Hanifa (RA), or this fatwa was not adopted in the Hanafi madhhab. That is, the fatwa of the Hanafi madhhab is that if a woman marries without a guardian, her marriage will not be void.

You may say –

The hadith says the marriage is void, so why did Abu Hanifa (RH) give a fatwa that the marriage is not void?

Yes, here a subtle secret lies hidden, which, because it is not known, many of us make slander or abuse against Imam al-A'zam. May Allah the Exalted forgive everyone!

The subtle secret is - the discussed hadith is a 'khabar wahid'. That is, the hadith is not of the mutawatir level. And for accepting a khabar wahid there are quite a few principles or conditions, and if they are found the hadith will be accepted; otherwise not!

Note: mutawatir and khabar wahid have been discussed earlier.

One of the conditions for accepting a khabar wahid hadith is -

" None of the narrators of the hadith should later forget or deny this hadith "

If a khabar wahid narrator is asked later and he acknowledges narrating the hadith, then the hadith will be accepted by unanimous agreement. And if he denies it or says he has forgotten it, then the hadith cannot be accepted as definitive.

Now see,

The above hadith is narrated by Sulayman ibn Musa from Imam al-Zuhri, Imam al-Zuhri narrates from Urwah, and Imam Urwah narrates from Hadrat A'ishah (RA) (the hadith is marfu').

See the narration of the hadith in light of the chart –

Musa ibn Sulayman → Imam al-Zuhri → Urwah → A'ishah radiyallahu anha

All in the above chain are thiqa narrators. There is no problem. However, once Imam Ibn Juraij (RH) asked Imam al-Zuhri (RH) about this hadith. Imam al-Zuhri replied that he did not know it.

So it was seen that one narrator in the discussed hadith is - Imam al-Zuhri (RH). And when he was later asked about this hadith, he said he did not know it.

Sources –

Musnad Ahmad 7/72

Sunan al-Tirmidhi 3/41

Sharh Ma'ani al-Athar li-l-Tahawi 3/8

Ma'alim as-Sunan li-l-Khattabi 2/567

As-Sunan al-Kubra li-l-Bayhaqi 7/106

( There are multiple sources, so let there be no doubt about Imam Juraij's (RH) question )

So you tell me - in light of the principle of accepting 'khabar wahid hadith' that we learned above, can this hadith be accepted?

Subhanallah!

The hadith is of the hasan level. Anyone seeing it would be ready to accept it; but how few knew what a great subtle matter lies hidden inside it __ !

Finally you tell me, has the Hanafi madhhab's not accepting this hadith been entirely non-fundamental? Been unjust? Or will you say that this hadith did not reach Abu Hanifa (RA)?

Allahu Akbar!

How can you make such slanders? If this hadith did not reach Abu Hanifa (RH), then how did he discuss the subtle matter concerning this hadith's narrator?

Fi amanillah!