Did Hadith Not Reach the Imams of the Madhhabs?
There are several fairly common misconceptions / statements in our society. For example,
1 - The imams of the madhhabs were faqihs. They were not muhaddiths.
2 - The imams of the madhhabs did not know enough hadith.
3 - Not all hadiths reached the imams of the madhhabs.
Roughly, quite a few such statements or common misconceptions have spread in our society. Such questions are often received from brothers who have newly returned to the religion.
And it is a natural thing for questions to come, where, to brothers newly walking on the path of the religion, it is said with a very juicy presentation -
" See, the imams of the madhhabs passed away between 80 AH and 241 AH. And all the hadith books, including Bukhari and Muslim, were compiled after that. So how could the imams get these hadiths? "
Anyone simple-minded can very easily be confused by such a logical-sounding statement. Without knowing the real history and the history of the Sharia, it is a common thing to be easily deceived by such an account.
Anyway, let me present the identity and some statements of those who spread such bizarre and absurd talk, creating a muddle of information among simple-minded religious brothers and hiding the real history.
Many shaykhs in Bangladesh spread the above muddled information. It is not possible for me to present everyone's discussion. But I present the statement of at least one with great respect.
A shaykh (may Allah preserve him) greatly trusted by the Salafi and Ahl al-Hadith brothers of Bangladesh says - ( I am not naming him for sound reasons )
" The famous, great four imams came in 80-241 AH and departed in this very period. Most of their time was when the famous six hadith books had not been completely compiled. In particular, in the period of Imam Abu Hanifa, Malik and Shafi'i, those famous hadith books had not even begun; rather, many had not even been born. As a result, it was not possible for all hadiths to be within their reach. "
Source - Sunnat-e-Rasul o Char Imamer Obosthan 93
The Shaykh has tried at greater length to explain that since hadith had not been compiled in the imams' time, not all hadiths reached them.
What a wonderful statement! If someone does not know the scope of the imams' knowledge and the history of hadith study, the Shaykh's statement may seem accurate and logical. But to a low-level student of hadith or any investigator of the Sharia, the statement is nothing but taken as mere humour.
In this piece it is not possible for me to prove how much scholarship each imam had acquired in hadith, or how many hadiths they had in store. Because that is a vast subject!
In reply to the statement of the Shaykh (may Allah preserve him), I present below a statement of Imam Ibn Taymiyyah (RA). In this there is the answer to the Shaykh's words, and a picture also emerges of how much the imams knew about hadith.
Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah (rahimahullah) says in his book of fatwas -
" بل الذين كانوا قبل جمع هذه الدواوين كانوا اعلم بالسنة من المتأخرين بكثير ، فكانت دواوينهم صدورهم التي تحوي أضعاف ما في الدواوين وهذا أمر لا يشك فيه من علم القضية "
Simple translation -
" The imams before the compilation of these books of hadith and Sunnah knew hadith and Sunnah far more than those after. Their books were - their chests, in which hadith and Sunnah were preserved in far greater quantity than in these books. No one who knows the relevant matter can doubt this. "
Source - Majmu' al-Fatawa 20/239
Honoured reader,
What did you understand? What did you infer from the quotation of Shaykh al-Islam? Those whose very chests were books of hadith, did they supposedly not know hadith? Supposedly not enough authentic hadith reached them?
Is the matter truly so? Or is it as Shaykh al-Islam (rahimahullah) has said?
Jazakumullahu khayran!