Does Finding an Authentic Hadith Make It Automatically Actionable?
Many of our dear religious brothers say - we act only when we find an authentic hadith; nothing else! The statement is very nice. But there is a little gap in understanding here. It is not enough for a hadith merely to be authentic; one must also see whether it is fit for practice. Read a small debate and discussion on this.
Some days ago a la-madhhabi brother came and said to me -
Brother, we follow only when we find an authentic hadith. Nothing else!
I then said -
Wow, that is very good! Well, could you tell me something by looking at hadith no. 187 of Sunan al-Tirmidhi?
He said -
It is written in the hadith - the Messenger (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) prayed Dhuhr and Asr, and Maghrib and Isha, together in Madinah without fear or rain.
I then said -
Well brother, are you acting on this hadith every day?
He said -
No, I am not acting on this.
I then said -
Why? How much easier the Prophet ﷺ has made it. What need do we have to take a separate break for Dhuhr; at Asr time we will pray Dhuhr and Asr together. And at Isha time we will pray Maghrib and Isha together.
See further, at the end of the hadith it is also written that Hadrat Ibn Abbas (RA) said:
The Prophet's ﷺ aim was to reduce hardship for the Ummah. So why are you putting yourself to hardship by praying four prayers in four times? Pray four in two times.
He said -
Perhaps this refers to prayer during travel.
I said -
No, see! It is written in the hadith itself that the Messenger ﷺ was then a resident in Madinah. Not travelling. And Imam al-Tirmidhi (RA) did not bring the hadith in the chapter on travel either. So why would it be for the time of travel?
He said -
All right, then I will find out later and let you know.
Then, yesterday the brother came and told me that Imam al-Tirmidhi (RA) says in Kitab al-'Ilal:
This hadith cannot be acted upon.
I said -
Inna lillah! What is this you say, brother? I see you have become a muqallid like us! I presented to you an authentic hadith of the Messenger ﷺ. And you are acting on the word of Imam al-Tirmidhi. Why are you leaving aside acting on the authentic hadith and acting on the word of Imam al-Tirmidhi (RA)?
I also said -
Brother, see, when in such matters we take the researched view of Imam al-A'zam Abu Hanifa (RA), you abuse us by calling us Hanafi muqallids. Yet you yourselves, under pressure, did taqlid of Imam al-Tirmidhi?! If our doing taqlid is unlawful, why is your doing taqlid lawful? Why this double standard?
I then also said -
Brother, see, Imam Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani (RH) wrote in Fath al-Bari 1/397: "There are many hadiths that are authentic but have been abrogated."
And in the very book you cited, Imam al-Tirmidhi (RH) also said that the honoured jurists understand the meaning of hadith best!
Finally I also said, the difference between you and us is that we do taqlid of the best jurists, while you, by whim, do taqlid of whichever shaykh at any time.
Note:- Slightly edited and refined, based on an incident narrated by Shaykh Mufti Bilal ibn Ali (may Allah preserve him)!
Besides, before considering any hadith you find actionable, the piece below needs to be read. I hope the matter will become clearer, insha Allah!
Please do not treat the science of hadith as stale rice. Do not consider a hadith finished merely because it is authentic. Do not suppose a hadith has breathed its last merely because it is da'if.
Many of us think that a hadith being authentic means starting to act. There is no room to think before or after, or no need to listen to the words of any faqih or muhaddith.
Yet dear brothers, there are many authentic hadiths of the Messenger ﷺ that carry the possibility of more than one meaning / purpose. There are also many hadiths that the Messenger ﷺ sometimes made specific and sometimes made general.
As Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah (RH) says -
والأحكام يبينها ' تارة بصيغة عامة وتارة بصيغة خاصة.
Translation -
The Messenger ﷺ said many rulings sometimes in words of broad meaning and sometimes in words of specific meaning."
Source - Minhaj as-Sunnah 1/309
A hadith carries the possibility of multiple interpretations and meanings, which must be judged considering various aspects. For an ordinary reader to finalise merely by reading the Bengali of a hadith is not right at all. Rather, it is extremely important to know the explanations of the jurists and muhaddiths. Otherwise, one may become confused and misguided.
As the imam of the sciences of hadith and fiqh, Abu Yusuf (rahimahullah), says -
ولحديث رسول الله' معاني، ووجوه، وتفسير لا يفهمه ولا يبصره إلا من أعانه الله عليه
"A saying of the Messenger ﷺ is rich in many meanings, full of various aspects and explanations. Only the one whom Allah the Exalted grants the ability is able to grasp it and reach its depth."
Source - ar-Radd ala Siyar al-Awza'i p. 14
See, the muhaddiths are saying - how many states a hadith can have. Yet many of us begin to act merely seeing the apparent form of a hadith and declare the opposite view false.
A hadith being authentic is a part indeed. But it is not everything about the hadith. A hadith has many aspects. Then one must act. For example -
1. The soundness of the chain and matn of the hadith
2. Uncovering the clear meaning and purpose of the hadith
3. Verifying whether the hadith is nasikh-mansukh
4. Seeing whether the hadith has any contradiction
5. Verifying whether the hadith was specific to the Messenger
After finishing all such verification, the muhaddiths and jurists make an operative decision on a hadith. Yet many of us think that once a hadith is authentic, everything is finished. And there is no need to look at anything else.
Support for the above statement is found in a statement of Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah (RH) -
فكم من حديث صحيح ومعناه فيه نزاع كثير
"There are many hadiths that are authentic but there is much disagreement in their meaning."
Source - Naqd Maratib al-Ijma' p. 304
Now think,
Where Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah (RH) is saying that even after a hadith is authentic, disagreement remains, many of us consider it sufficient for practice right after seeing a hadith is authentic, which is not the correct method!