What Are the Principles of Issuing Fatwas?
If anyone wants to understand the Quran or become fully proficient in the Quran, he must first pay attention to reading translations. While reading the translation, quite a few hard-to-understand matters of the Quran will come up. Then it will seem that translation alone is not enough; rather, one must read tafsir, or books of commentary. Then, while studying books of tafsir, some terminology will be hard to understand, or some discussions will come up that are not easily understood. Then you will have to read the books "'Ulum at-Tafsir", or "the principles of tafsir", as a tool of tafsir.
1
That is, when you set out to understand the Quran fully, you will necessarily have to read in sequence: translation → tafsir → and principles. Otherwise, maturity in taking the Quran to heart will not come to you. For this reason, in every Islamic university, in the "Quran Department", alongside translation and tafsir, 'Ulum al-Quran, or books on the principles of the Quran, are taught as a major or compulsory subject.
2.
When you set out to study hadith, at the first level you will give attention to reading translations. As you read, you will come across some hadiths whose apparent meaning you do not understand. Then you will be compelled to read books of hadith commentary. After studying the commentary on each hadith, there will come quite a lot of review of the grade of that hadith and so on. Again you will face extreme difficulty understanding those. Then again you will have to read "'Ulum al-Hadith", or the principles of hadith and so on.
That is, if you want to acquire complete knowledge of hadith, then alongside the translation of hadith you must also know the commentary of hadith. And finally, for maturity, you must also know the principles of hadith. Otherwise, mistakes and errors may come in through not knowing how to verify the grade of hadith and the rules of preference in mutually conflicting matters. For this reason, every Islamic university's "Hadith Department" keeps, alongside hadith commentary, a compulsory subject named 'Ulum al-Hadith, or the principles of hadith.
3.
If you now want to understand fiqh, you will have to read the textbooks of some fixed madhhab or the comparative (muqaran) texts of the four madhhabs. While studying fiqh, when you read the evidentiary review of each madhhab, you will see that many things are coming up that you did not know before. Then you will be compelled to return to usul al-fiqh, or the principles of fiqh (which has seemed to me so far the hardest subject). When an imam gives preference to some evidence, he does so keeping the usul, or principles, before him.
That is, if you want to get complete knowledge of fiqh, then alongside reading rulings and issues you must understand usul al-fiqh, or the principles of fiqh. Otherwise, you will not be able to understand on the basis of which principle an imam gave his evidentiary discussion. And through not understanding you will think that Abu Hanifa (RA) has made a mistake here! Hadith did not even reach Abu Hanifa!! Abu Hanifa did not even know hadith! Etcetera....
For this reason, in every Islamic university's fiqh department, alongside rulings and issues, usul al-fiqh, or the principles of fiqh, is taught compulsorily. In our department the whole university life teaches just this subject!
4.
Now your study of the Quran, hadith and fiqh is all finished. The desire arises that you want to be a mufti. Then, alongside acquiring the above knowledge of the Quran, hadith and fiqh, you must master two more important standards. They are -
a. You must internalise well the qawa'id fiqhiyyah ( قواعد فقهية ), or the rules of fiqh. Because many rulings are solved on the basis of these specialised rules.
b. You must have sufficient study of the maqasid shar'iyyah ( مقاصد الشريعة), or the intended purposes of the Sharia. Otherwise, you will face difficulty in giving a fatwa on any contemporary matter.
In short, to be a learned and wise mufti, alongside knowledge of the Quran, hadith and fiqh you must fully know the above two subjects, "qawa'id fiqhiyyah and maqasid ash-shari'ah". For this reason, in every Islamic university's fiqh or ifta department, alongside the Quran, hadith and fiqh, the above two subjects are taught as major subjects.
5.
One of its main conditions for giving a fatwa is - one must know the maqasid ash-shari'ah. A fatwa is not merely telling the rulings of earlier imams. Rather, a fatwa is the evidentiary discussion of the Quran and Hadith, keeping the maqasid ash-shari'ah in front of one, with consideration of the situation.
Even those who follow a madhhab extremely sometimes have to move away from the view of their own madhhab. Because, considering the environment and circumstances, one has to go to such a decision. In this, the purpose is __ maqasid ash-shari'ah, or the purposes of the Sharia.
In the last part, I want to say a few words about the maqasid ash-shari'ah. Because of being ignorant of this subject in our country, many give fatwas in such a way that debate begins at once. In truth, if fatwas were given keeping the maqasid ash-shari'ah in front, such debate would never arise.
What is maqasid ash-shari'ah? What is the necessity of maqasid ash-shari'ah? I will conclude the piece by shedding a little light on these two matters, insha Allah.
a. What is maqasid ash-shari'ah?
Ibn Rajab (RA) says - the purposes with which the Lawgiver has imposed rulings are the maqasid ash-shari'ah. (1)
Imam al-Shatibi (RA) says - it is agreed that the rulings the Sharia has imposed on us have a purpose. And that is our broad benefit (in this world and the hereafter). And this is the maqasid ash-shari'ah. (2)
b. What is the necessity of maqasid ash-shari'ah?
Imam al-Shatibi (RA) says - when a person reaches such a level that he can understand the intended purpose of the Lawgiver in every area of the Sharia, and can uncover the secret behind every ruling, then he has acquired a quality by which he can represent the Messenger ﷺ in giving fatwas. (3)
Besides, on the necessity of maqasid ash-shari'ah Dr. Faisal ibn Sa'ud (may Allah preserve him) mentions in his outstanding book (علم مقاصد الشريعة الإسلامية) -
1 - It is a knowledge from which a mujtahid or mufti can never be independent. Because a mujtahid or mufti must keep the maqasid ash-shari'ah in front of him in his ijtihad. And fatwas must be given around the maqasid ash-shari'ah. Any word contrary to the Sharia is never acceptable.
2 - It is a knowledge by which the reality of every evidence and proof is known and the purpose is understood. In particular, the necessity of maqasid ash-shari'ah in giving preference in conflicting matters is undeniable.
3 - It is a knowledge by which the fiqh experience of a student and teacher of the fiqh department becomes firm and strong.
4 - It is a knowledge to which every judge / administrator / guardian must return. Because, during judicial work, keeping the maqasid ash-shari'ah in front, they must abolish general corruption ('amm mufsidah) and establish general welfare ('amm maslahah).
5 - It is a knowledge by which certainty and faith in Allah increase. One understands Allah's grace upon His servants. (4)
Besides, he sets out several more necessities and benefits of the maqasid ash-shari'ah, from which a teacher or student at the religious level can never be independent. In particular, for those who work in the field of da'wah and give fatwas in society, it is essential to study maqasid ash-shari'ah, without which it will not do!
Khitam al-misk: reading the long discussion, many may say in embarrassment that the religion is easy. One can give fatwas just by reading hadith through Bengali translation and applications. What is all this? The Messenger told us to follow the Quran and Hadith. Not all this?
I will say one thing to the brothers: not one of the matters discussed in the present piece is anything outside the Quran and Hadith. Rather, all this arrangement is in order to understand the Quran and Hadith with complete knowledge. Jazakumullahu khayran!
_______
(1) Muntaha al-Usul wa al-Amal 184
(2) al-Muwafaqat 139
(3) al-Muwafaqat 106
(4) Maqasid ash-Shari'ah 54