Chapter Four · Miscellaneous

To Learn a Ruling, Should One Read Hadith or Books of Fiqh?

On the path of living by the Islamic rulings, at every step one must go forward knowing the rulings and issues. That is why some of us read the Quran and Hadith directly, and others study books of fiqh.

The topic under discussion is - for an ordinary Muslim, which is safer for learning rulings and issues? The Quran and Hadith directly, or books of fiqh?

( Let me say beforehand that there is no substitute for the reward or necessity of reading the Quran and Hadith in general. Here I am just discussing which is safer for understanding rulings and issues. )

Before clarifying the matter, I think it is important to set out the difference between hadith and books of fiqh -

Hadith books: -

Where all kinds of hadith are included. All hadiths are collected, including authentic, da'if, those specific to the Messenger, nasikh-mansukh and so on. Details such as which is applicable in practice and which is not are generally not found in hadith collections.

Books of fiqh: -

All the rulings and issues needed at every step of life are presented with evidence and proofs. Worship, transactions, hudud and so on are arranged nicely part by part.

The most interesting thing is that the rulings and issues are arranged with the evidence of the hadith that is applicable in practice.

The summary of both comes to this -

By reading a hadith book an ordinary Muslim cannot know which hadith is applicable in practice and which is not.

But by reading a book of fiqh an ordinary Muslim will easily understand which hadith is applicable in practice. Because the honoured jurists, after vast review, separate nasikh from mansukh and state in the ruling the hadith most applicable in practice.

So it became clear to us that those who have an idea of the nasikh-mansukh of hundreds of thousands of hadiths and so on can read hadith directly, learn rulings and issues and act on them. And for those who are ordinary Muslims, reading books of fiqh is necessary.

Because an ordinary Muslim does not know -

1 - which is hadith and which is Sunnah!

2 - which ruling has been abrogated and which remains.

3 - which is nasikh and which is mansukh.

4 - the mutually conflicting matters of hadith.

There are also many matters in hadith that an ordinary Muslim can never know. So, merely to learn rulings and issues, reading books of fiqh is very necessary and indeed safe for an ordinary Muslim.

Now let me shed a little light before you on the nasikh-mansukh of hadith -

Mansukh - a hadith whose ruling has been abrogated

Nasikh - a hadith that has abrogated a ruling and brought some new ruling

A question may arise -

Is there nasikh-mansukh in this way in the hadith of the Messenger ﷺ? Yes! There are many such hadiths whose ruling was later abrogated. This was discovered by the honoured muhaddithin, or the Messenger ﷺ said it in part, or explained it by acting contrary to it.

Some principles for understanding the nasikh-mansukh of hadith -

1 - The Messenger ﷺ acted one way early in life and later acted another way.

2 - The Messenger ﷺ first said one thing and later said another.

3 - The Messenger: said one thing but acted differently.

4 - The Messenger ﷺ said one thing, and the Companions acted differently.

Besides this there are many more principles in the light of which the nasikh-mansukh of hadith becomes clear.

The first independent book on the nasikh-mansukh of the hadith of the Messenger ﷺ was written by Imam Hafiz Ibn Shahin (385 AH) (rahimahullah)! In the book he included 666 hadiths that exist among us but whose ruling no longer remains. That is, the Ummah cannot act on them.

Finally, let me explain with an example that it is never possible for an ordinary Muslim to learn rulings and issues by reading hadith directly, unless he reads books of fiqh alongside.

It is in the hadith book -

ما رواه أبو داود والترمذي من حديث معاوية: من شرب الخمر فاجلدوه، فإن عاد في الرابعة فاقتلوه.

Narrated by a sound chain, the Messenger ﷺ said: " Whoever drinks wine, flog him. If he drinks again, even if he does so four times, then kill him. "

It is in the book of fiqh -

If a person drinks wine, he will be flogged. If he repeats the same act, he will be flogged again. He can never be killed.

If you are an ordinary Muslim and read the above-mentioned hadith, you will say, the punishment for repeated wine drinking is the death penalty! But if you see a mufti giving a fatwa that the death penalty cannot be given for repeated wine drinking, then what will your reaction be?

Surely you will say, this mufti does not know hadith. Even if he knows, he does not follow it. This mufti does blind taqlid. This mufti is a madhhab-worshipper. This mufti sahib... perhaps you will say much more!

In truth, you, an ordinary Muslim, do not know at all that this hadith is mansukh, that is, this ruling has been abrogated. It will no longer be acted upon.

Imam al-Nawawi (RA), in his commentary on Sahih Muslim, clearly states and says:

" This hadith has been abrogated. A drinker of wine can never be given the death penalty. Rather, he will be flogged as many times as he drinks "

My dear brother,

The misunderstanding about the madhhab begins from exactly this place. Many of us do not know the nasikh-mansukh of hadith. Yet we read huge hadith collections directly!

And at the slightest case where some fiqh ruling is contrary to a hadith, we suddenly say -

1 - Abu Hanifa (RA) was against hadith

2 - Hadith never reached Abu Hanifa (RA)

3 - Abu Hanifa (RA) gave qiyas priority over hadith.

Al-iyadhu billah!

May Allah keep all of us away from jahalah (ignorance) and grant a true understanding of the Quran and Hadith. Ameen!