Chapter Two · Taqlid

Why Taqlid?

We know that the rulings of the Sharia are of two kinds –

1 – Clear rulings

These are rulings that Allah and the Messenger ﷺ have made clear. In such rulings there is no need to do taqlid of anyone. For example: prayer, fasting, zakat, hajj, the punishment for adultery and so on.

2 – Unclear rulings

These are rulings that are not clearly stated in the Quran and Hadith. The mujtahid imams gather them through research. In such rulings it is valid to do taqlid of any imam.

Unclear rulings generally arise for several reasons –

1 – Evidences that apparently conflict

Sometimes, on some ruling, mutually conflicting evidences are found. Apparently both seem authentic. In this case what will an ordinary person do? Without doubt, they will take the view of some imam. Since an ordinary person does not have the ability to resolve conflicting matters.

2 – Words with more than one meaning

Some words are found in the Quran or Hadith that can carry more than one meaning. In this case, how will an ordinary person understand which is the correct meaning? It is never possible to understand. As a result, in this case an ordinary person has to take the view of an imam.

3 – Nasikh and mansukh (abrogating and abrogated)

There are nasikh and mansukh in the Quran, and in the Hadith too there are countless. In the Hadith you see once that the Messenger ﷺ did something this way. Elsewhere you find that the Messenger ﷺ did not do it this way. So how will an ordinary person understand which is to be acted on? Certainly, in this case the imams must be followed.

4 – Sihhat al-istidlal (soundness of derivation)

You find a hadith, but was it meant only for the Messenger, or is it to be acted on by everyone? How will an ordinary person understand that? Certainly, in this case too the words of the imams must be heeded. Because the imams exercised ijtihad on such matters and reached a correct view.

There are many other reasons besides, for which taqlid must be done. For this Almighty Allah commands in verse 43 of Surah an-Nahl in the Holy Quran –

'If you do not know, then ask the people of knowledge'