Chapter Two · Taqlid

Is There Anyone Without Taqlid?

Is there anyone without taqlid? In a word - no, no one in our time is without taqlid. Where we have already discussed that the Companions, the Tabi'in and the predecessors did taqlid, how can we, the later ones, go without taqlid?

Many of our dear brothers claim, we do not do taqlid. We do not believe any word without evidence. Very good. But is that the reality?

Let us review a little: when, where and how do those of our brothers who claim not to do taqlid in fact do taqlid!

Suppose we took out a book of fiqh to learn a ruling -

In the light of research from the Quran and Hadith we adopted a ruling that is mufta bihi (the one on which the fatwa is given). That's it, we have become blind muqallids!

They took out an app or a Bengali book to learn a hadith -

Seeing "Sahih" written in a corner of the app or in the footnote of the book, they adopted the hadith. That's it, they have become ghayr muqallids.

I don't understand this reckoning. Without going anywhere near the five accepted conditions for a hadith to be sahih, they began to act just by seeing "Sahih" written in a corner. Is this not blind taqlid?

Suppose there are five conditions for a hadith to be sahih:

1. The chain must be connected.

2. The narrator must be 'adil (upright).

3. The narrator must be dabit (precise).

4. It must not be shadhdh (anomalous).

5. It must not be mu'allal (having a hidden defect).

Without having even a particle of idea about even one of the above five matters, or without verifying, however it came about a muhaddith said it is sahih, and they believed his word and started acting on it.

How do they become ghayr muqallids by this?

Dear reader,

What do you think? Those who go about saying, we do not do taqlid. Do all of them -

1 - know everything about the ittisal (connectedness) of a hadith?

2 - know in detail about the 'adalah of the narrator?

3 - know about the memory of the narrator?

4 - have insight into the shudhudh of a hadith?

5 - have knowledge about the 'illal of a hadith?

Brother, I believe that the lion's share of them have no idea even of these terms. Yet at the end of the day some of my brothers will claim, we do not do blind taqlid of anyone. We act after verifying!

Wow! Isn't that beautiful?

So we can say without hesitation that each of us does taqlid in some way. Some of us perhaps admit it with our mouths, and some perhaps do not. That's the only difference!

Take the trouble to read another piece on an example of taqlid –

After the Holy Quran, the two most authentic books are -

1. Sahih al-Bukhari

2. Sahih Muslim

No one has any doubt about the hadiths of Bukhari and Muslim. Muqallids and ghayr muqallids all agree that all hadiths in these two books are authentic or sahih!

Well, in what sense and for what reasons were the hadiths of Bukhari and Muslim sahih? How many of us ordinary Muslims know?

Perhaps you will say that only a handful know, and the rest are mostly an ignorant public!

So then, without knowing any reason or reality for the hadiths of Bukhari and Muslim being sahih, we simply close our eyes and accept outright, only because they are in Bukhari and Muslim ____ that the hadiths of Bukhari and Muslim are sahih.

Is this not blind taqlid?

Honoured reader, if accepting something without understanding is called blind taqlid, then is following the hadiths of Bukhari and Muslim absolutely, without knowing the reason for their being sahih, not blind taqlid?

May Allah the Exalted grant all of us correct understanding!

Allahumma salli ala Muhammad!