Chapter Two · Taqlid

Was There Taqlid in the Era of the Companions?

Allahu Akbar! Taqlid is an everlasting matter of the Sharia, which has continued in succession since the era of the Companions. I do not understand why or how some of our brothers oppose taqlid. May Allah grant everyone correct understanding!

Dear reader,

In this piece I will present to you taqlid in the era of the Companions. And there are abundant examples of taqlid in the era of the Companions; out of thousands of proofs I will present just one proof before you. For the wise and thoughtful, one proof is enough, insha Allah!

Before this, let me make one thing clear: the claim of our brothers is that taqlid means blind belief, I mean accepting someone's word without evidence. So let us see whether the Companions ever accepted any statement or fatwa without evidence!

It is narrated in Sahih al-Bukhari from Hadrat al-Aswad ibn Yazid (RA) that,

"The Messenger ﷺ sent Hadrat Mu'adh ibn Jabal (RA) to us as teacher and amir. We then asked him about a man who died leaving one daughter and one sister (they asked about the distribution of their inheritance). Then he gave the fatwa to give half to the sister and half to the daughter.

Source – Bukhari, 6734

Dear reader,

Here several things are noteworthy –

1 – Mu'adh ibn Jabal (RA) gave a fatwa without mentioning evidence.

2 – The questioners accepted it without knowing the evidence.

If accepting any fatwa without evidence is called blind taqlid, and if this taqlid is haram, then how could the honoured Companions do this haram act?

Al-iyadhu billah! We believe that no haram act can occur from the Companions, insha Allah. The honoured Companions certainly used to ask the Messenger. Junior Companions used to learn from senior Companions. And in this way the practice of taqlid has continued through the ages. But the sad thing is - in recent times some say that accepting anyone's word without evidence is blind taqlid, and that this taqlid is supposedly haram. May Allah protect everyone from saying such excess.

And acknowledging that taqlid has continued since the era of the Companions, the famous Salafi scholar of Arabia Shaykh Muhammad ibn Salih al-Uthaymeen (RH) says –

"There is no doubt that from the era of the Companions up to this era of ours there have been people who, through ignorance or immature knowledge, cannot derive the rulings and issues of the Sharia by themselves. So they will ask the people of knowledge, the scholars of the Sharia. They will accept whatever the scholars say. And accepting their words is itself called taqlid"

On the next page, right at the end, the Shaykh (rahimahullah) says –

"The reality is that taqlid has existed since the era of the Companions. Then he narrates a verse of the Quran"

Source – Majmu' Fatawa, page 404

Subhanallah!

Now think about the words of some of our brothers. How much hatred they fill themselves with when they hear the name of taqlid. Yet what is a Salafi shaykh, recognised among Arabs and non-Arabs and known to all, saying about taqlid? And what hatred do our religious brothers hold about taqlid?

Anyway, from the fatwa of the Shaykh (RH) several things became clear to us -

1. Taqlid existed in the era of the Companions too. Therefore, those who oppose taqlid are in reality denying the actions of the Companions. Nauzubillah!

2. Taqlid is permissible and in accordance with the Sharia. Those who consider taqlid haram are in fact disobeying a definitive ruling of the Sharia. Astaghfirullah!

3. Those who are unable to derive the rulings and issues of the Sharia by themselves must certainly do taqlid. Otherwise several verses of the Quran will be denied.

Barakallah!