Are Taqlid and Ittiba' Different?
By now we have learned what taqlid is, why, what its ruling is, what the fatwas of Arab scholars are, and so on. Now the matter of taqlid and ittiba' needs to be made clear. Because in our country many people propagate that taqlid and ittiba' are different matters, and that taqlid is haram while ittiba' is halal.
Dear reader,
In truth taqlid and ittiba' are the same thing. Both are synonymous in the literal sense, and in technical usage they carry the same purpose. Note: some have taken taqlid to mean blind belief and ittiba' to mean belief with evidence. In fact, since no such definition exists anywhere in the Quran and Hadith, we cannot absolutely accept such a difficult claim or anyone's personal thinking.
Note the literal meaning of both, since no fixed identity for either has been laid down by the Sharia. Anyway, the meaning of taqlid and ittiba' is to follow or to imitate.
Qadi Muhammad A'la al-Thanawi (rahimahullah) says,
Taqlid is - to follow, in ittiba', the words and deeds of another. Source – Kashshaf Istilahat al-Funun, 1178
Dear reader, see - the word ittiba' itself is used in the definition of taqlid. So this proves that in essence taqlid and ittiba' are the same, or identical. But if someone claims that taqlid means blind belief and ittiba' means seeing belief, then I would say - bring proof from the Quran or Hadith in support of your statement! In truth the Quran and Hadith have not defined any such thing.
That taqlid and ittiba' are the same, or identical, in practice and not merely in speech, you will, I hope, understand by reading the short debate below.
One day in the canteen, an Assamese Bengali classmate of mine and I were eating together. In passing, I asked -
Are you a muqallid?
He said -
No!
I said -
Then what?
He said -
I do ittiba'; I do not do taqlid of anyone.
I said -
What is the difference between ittiba' and taqlid?
He said -
Taqlid means following someone without evidence, and ittiba' means following someone with evidence.
I said -
Good! Now I have understood completely. Well then, I understand you do not do taqlid, but do you do ittiba' of someone?
He said -
Of course, I do ittiba' of all the Salaf.
I said -
So do you follow, that is do ittiba' of, all the Salaf with evidence?
He said -
Yes, why not?
I said -
MashaAllah! Well then, right now do you know all the evidences of the Salaf? Or have them memorised?
He said -
What is this? Why must they be memorised? And is it even possible to know the evidence for every ruling?
I said -
Why? Didn't you say you do ittiba' of the Salaf? And you said ittiba' means following with evidence? How can there be ittiba' without knowing the evidence?
He said -
Oh brother, even without knowing the evidence, I believe that the words of the Salaf have evidence. So I do ittiba'.
I said -
Poor brother, those who do taqlid also believe that those they do taqlid of surely have evidence. So where does the difference between ittiba' and taqlid remain?
He said -
Oh brother, leave all this! Leave this discussion and tell me instead, when will you get married?
I said -
I will get married, that is certain. But I won't tell you!
He said -
Why?
I said -
I don't have any evidence (document) right now that I will marry. And there is no point telling you about marriage without evidence. Even if I told you, you wouldn't believe me. Because you don't accept anyone's word without evidence.
From the next table, a downright local Bengali mischievous friend of ours was listening to all this quarrelling. He shouted out -
Oh come on! "What's lau is what's kodu" __ how long will you debate this? Whether it's lau or kodu, it's the same to eat! No one can tell them apart when eating! So "the neck is called ghar and the nape is called gordana, and the nape is called ghar." How long will you quarrel over these things?
Hayyakumullah!