Was There Taqlid Before the Fourth Century AH?
Honoured reader,
Ahsanallahu ilaykum!
Let me say a few words briefly on the above title. Those who have read the history of the Sharia must know that taqlid shakhsi, or following an individual, is proven from the era of the Companions. We discussed this earlier.
In our country many religious brothers say that the Hanafi madhhab means taqlid shakhsi, and that taqlid shakhsi is haram!
There are two points in their claim –
1. Hanafis only do taqlid shakhsi
2. Taqlid shakhsi is haram
One day, as I was reading, at one point I found a wonderful piece of history in the collected fatwas of Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah (RH). In it, just as taqlid shakhsi is mentioned, so there is fitting proof that other madhhabs besides the Hanafi also did taqlid shakhsi.
Imam Ibn Taymiyyah (rahimahullah) says -
والاوزاعي إمام أهل الشام وقد كانوا على مذهبه الى المأة الرا بعة
Simple Bengali translation -
"Imam al-Awza'i (rahimahullah) (he was an imam of the second century) was an imam. The people of Sham were on his madhhab up to the fourth century."
Source - (2/538)
From this small piece of information from Imam Ibn Taymiyyah (rahimahullah) several things become clear -
1. From the second century AH until the fourth century AH, a huge part of the Ummah (Sham: essentially the coordinating region of four of today's countries) were followers of one fixed madhhab, or did taqlid shakhsi.
2. Taqlid shakhsi was practised at various times in other madhhabs besides the Hanafi. It is unjust to impose it on the Hanafis alone.
3. From the second century AH until the fourth century AH, the people of Sham did taqlid shakhsi. What does this prove? Will those who make a great uproar about taqlid shakhsi call all the people of Sham misguided? In Sham at that time there were countless muhaddiths, mufassirs and faqihs!
Jazakumullahu khayran