Chapter Two · Taqlid

What Is Taqlid in the Eyes of Arab Scholars?

Alhamdulillah, in our country there is considerable following of Arab scholars. People accept the fatwas and views of Arab scholars without hesitation. In the present discussion we will learn the opinion of several famous Arab shaykhs on taqlid.

I love from the heart all the shaykhs, including the Salafi shaykhs, who follow Ahl as-Sunnah in the world. Without any special reason, among them I love Shaykh Uthaymeen (rahimahullah) a little more from the heart. For this reason I read his fatwa books, usul books and books on creed very much. I take benefit from them.

On that basis, in this piece I will discuss with you the fatwas of Shaykh Uthaymeen (rahimahullah) on the madhhab, on taqlid, and on following the madhhab of one's own country, insha Allah!

Shaykh Uthaymeen (rahimahullahu ta'ala) says on doing taqlid for ordinary people -

أن يكون المقلد عاميا لا يستطيع معرفة الحكم بنفسه، ففرضه التقليد، لقوله تعالي - فاسألوا أهل الذكر إن كنتم لا تعلمون

Simple translation -

For ordinary people who are unable to know the rulings of the Sharia directly, taqlid is fard. Because Allah the Exalted has said,

" If you do not know, then ask the people of knowledge."

Source: - al-Usul min 'Ilm al-Usul, p. 87

Note that when the scholars of our country say taqlid is necessary, many perhaps puff up in anger. Yet see the fatwa of a famous Salafi shaykh of Arabia (RH). He did not merely speak of doing taqlid; rather, he issued a fatwa that it is fard.

Now let us see what fatwa Shaykh Uthaymeen (rahimahullah) gave on following the madhhab current in one's own country -

لأن فرضك أنت هو التقليد، وأحق من تقلد علماؤك، ولو قلدت من كان خارج بلادك أدى ذلك إلى الفوضى في أمر ليس عليه دليل شرعي. فالعامي يجب عليه أن يقلد علماء بلده الذين يثق بهم.

Simple translation -

Surely your duty is - to do taqlid. And the greatest claimants to your taqlid are the scholars of your own (country). If you do not do that and instead do taqlid of scholars of foreign countries, it will create unruliness and disorder. So it is the duty of ordinary people to follow the scholars of their own country.

Source: - Liqa'at al-Bab al-Maftuh 19/32

Shall I say anything more?

In truth there is no need to say anything. For the intelligent and those who seek the truth, these two small fatwas are enough. And for those who like disorder or fitna, even a thousand fatwas will not help.

Now let us see what the fatwa of the famous Salafi shaykh of Arabia, Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab al-Najdi (rahimahullah), is on taqlid and the madhhab –

ونحن أيضاً في الفروع، على مذهب الإمام أحمد بن حنبل، ولا ننكر على من قلد أحد الأئمة الأربعة، دون غيرهم، لعدم ضبط مذاهب الغير؛ الرافضة، والزيدية، والإمامية، ونحوهم؛ ولا نقرهم ظاهراً على شيء من مذاهبهم الفاسدة، بل نجبرهم على تقليد أحد الأئمة الأربعة .

Translation: In fiqh matters we are followers of the madhhab of Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal (RH). We raise no objection to those who do taqlid of any one of the four imams. Because (the madhhabs of the four imams exist in compiled form. Whereas) the madhhabs of others do not exist in compiled form. However, we do not recognise the following of false madhhabs and doctrines such as the Rafidah, Zaydiyyah, Imamiyyah and so on. Rather, we compel them to do taqlid of one of the four imams.

Source - ad-Durar as-Saniyyah 1/277

Is that all? Once a lie was spread about him, that he was against the madhhab and taqlid. In reply the Shaykh (rahimahullah) says -

قوله : إني مبطل كتب المذاهب الأربعة، وإني أقول إن الناس من ستمائة سنة ليسوا على شيء وإني أدعي الاجتهاد، وإني خارج عن التقليد... هذا بهتان عظيم .

Translation: Those who are spreading in my name that I call the books of the four madhhabs false, that I supposedly say people have been in error for six hundred years, that I have claimed ijtihad and abandoned taqlid, (in reply to this propaganda of theirs I will say only this,) this is a false accusation against me.

Source - ar-Rasa'il ash-Shakhsiyyah, p. 4

The writing is getting long; otherwise I would present here the fatwas of all the famous Salafi shaykhs one by one. But I think that for anyone intelligent and seeking the truth, the fatwas of the above two shaykhs are enough, insha Allah.

Jazakumullah!