Chapter Two · Taqlid

What Is the Ruling on Taqlid?

We know that the mukallaf (one on whom a ruling is imposed) in the Sharia is of two kinds –

1. Mujtahid - one who will research on his own and derive rulings from the Quran and Hadith.

2. Muqallid - one who will follow a mujtahid imam / scholar.

The Ummah has only these two roads. You are either a mujtahid or a muqallid. There is no room for a third, that is, an alternative kind.

Anyway, about the ruling on the muqallid Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah (rahimahullah) says -

من كان مقلدا لزم حكم التقليد ،فلم يرجح ولم يزيف ولم يصيب ولم يخطئ

That is, whoever is a muqallid, the ruling of taqlid applies to him. He can never give preference (tarjih) in matters of disagreement. He cannot label any view as fabricated or wrong. He cannot label any view as correct or incorrect.

Source - Majmu' al-Fatawa, Ibn Taymiyyah 35/233

From the outstanding fatwa of Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah (RA) we understood that a muqallid can never -

1 - give preference to a personal view in matters of disagreement

2 - has no right to call any view fabricated

3 - has no right to call any single view correct

4 - has no right to call any view wrong

The second fatwa -

In our country it has become a fashion for some religious brothers that they follow a madhhab, but sometimes Hanafi, sometimes Shafi'i or Hanbali. That is, whichever suits them at the time, that is what they follow. When scholars oppose this, they say so nicely _

" All four madhhabs are authentic. So following any one of them will do "

In truth, they understand, yet pretend not to understand, that through this statement the desires of their own nafs are being fulfilled. Yet following the desires of the nafs is clearly haram.

Let us learn the fatwa of Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah (RA) on this matter –

فيكونون في وقت يقلدون من يفسده وفي وقت يقلدون من يصححه بحسب الغرض والهوى ومثل هذا لايجوز باتفاق الائمة ونظير هذا ان يعتقد الرجل ثبوت شفعة الجوار اذا كان طالبا لها ويعتقد عدم الثبوت اذا كان مشتريا فان هذا لايجوز بالاجماع...لان ذالك يفتح باب التلاعب بالدين وفتح للذريعة الى ان يكون التحليل والتحريم بحسب الاهواء.

Translation –

If it suits their interest and desire, they follow the imam who gives a fatwa that the matter is impermissible according to their interest. And when it goes against their interest, the very same people follow an imam who gives a fatwa that the matter is permissible. Such unbridled slavery to desire is impermissible and unlawful according to all the imams. An example of this kind of matter is: when one is a neighbour and a claimant, saying that the 'right of pre-emption in purchase' is valid on the basis of being a neighbour, but when one is the buyer, saying it is invalid for the neighbour. Seeking out, on every matter, the madhhab that suits one's interest and acting accordingly is not lawful by ijma', the agreement of all. Because it opens the way to playing with the religion and opens the way to determining halal and haram according to one's own whims. (Fatawa Ibn Taymiyyah 32/100-101)

Note:- There is nothing more to add here by way of remark. A learned and sensible reader will understand just by reading the easily readable fatwa that following, according to convenience, the opinions of several madhhabs at once is not permissible in Islam.

Hayyakumullah!