What Are the Usul of the Hanafi Madhhab? (1)
Usul means principles. Principles in the light of which rulings and issues are derived from the Quran and Hadith. Usul, or principles, exist in every madhhab. In this piece we will learn two wonderful principles of the Hanafi madhhab, insha Allah. By this, many of our misconceptions will be removed, insha Allah!
What are usul, or principles, anyway?
We will act on whatever we find in the Hadith. Right?
People say the above words for two reasons –
1. Ignorance about hadith
2. Ignorance about usul
Yet the rule is - after knowing a hadith, to act on it, one must know the status of that hadith and the principles of acting. Otherwise, one can easily fall into confusion.
What is usul?
And what is its necessity?
Or what are the rules of its use?
I will explain the answers to all such questions through a short usul, or principle, of the Hanafi madhhab. Allah is the Granter of success!
Suppose,
One usul of the Hanafi madhhab is -
If a narrator narrates a hadith and the hadith is authentic. But the narrator acts contrary to it. Then the principle of the Hanafi madhhab is - the narrator's hadith is not to be counted; rather, his practice is what is counted. In this case the narrated hadith will be considered mansukh (abrogated) and the practice nasikh (abrogating).
For example -
1. Abu Hurayrah (RA) narrates that the Messenger ﷺ said - If a dog drinks from the vessel of any of you, let him wash it seven times. (Bukhari; Muslim)
Look at this hadith! It clearly says that if a dog has drunk from a vessel, it must be washed seven times. And the hadith was narrated by Abu Hurayrah (radiyallahu anhu)!
But in another authentic hadith it is found that Abu Hurayrah (RA) himself, in this situation, gave a fatwa to wash only three times rather than seven!
Source – Sunan al-Daraqutni, 1/66
Now it was seen -
There is a mutual contradiction between the hadith narrated by Abu Hurayrah (RA) and his fatwa. That is, in the hadith he narrated, seven times is mentioned, and in his practice three times is found. In this situation, what is the duty of the Ummah? The duty is to set up a principle, or to turn to usul!
At this point Imam al-A'zam Abu Hanifa (RA) gives the fatwa that the ruling will be established on the narrator's practice. Because the narrated hadith may be mansukh. Otherwise, a Companion of exalted rank would never act contrary to the word of the Messenger ﷺ.
Now,
Let me tell you one last thing -
Suppose,
You are reading a hadith book and a book of fatwas of the Hanafi madhhab.
1. In the hadith book you read –
The Messenger ﷺ said - if a dog drinks, the vessel must be washed seven times.
2. In the fatwa book you read –
Imam al-A'zam said - if a dog drinks, washing three times is enough.
You know neither the usul nor the ruling of the hadith - yet after reading both you say -
Disaster! What has Abu Hanifa (RH) done? The Messenger said seven times and he gave a fatwa of three times!!
Then perhaps you will say further, how astonishing! Abu Hanifa does not know any hadith at all. He only does qiyas. Surely, this hadith did not reach Abu Hanifa!
My dear brother,
The matter of the madhhab gets stuck at exactly this place. You are perhaps seeing with literal knowledge - Abu Hanifa (RA) did not take Bukhari / Muslim or other authentic hadiths despite their existing. But you have perhaps not known the story behind it. That is why you are saying random things at will! May Allah grant everyone correct understanding!
Fi hifzillah!
2
A wonderful usul, or principle, of the Hanafi madhhab, and the removal of confusion about the madhhab
I have said earlier that, whether hadith or fiqh, because of not knowing the principles, confusion arises in many minds. As a result, insults or ill thoughts about any madhhab easily come. In truth, if someone knows and understands well the separate principles of each madhhab, then I hope no one will stand the madhhab against the Quran and Hadith.
A wonderful principle, or usul, of the Hanafi madhhab in the matter of hadith is -
" If a khabar wahid hadith is contrary to, or an addition to, a general discussion of the Holy Quran, then the general discussion of the Quran is to be acted on. A khabar wahid cannot be taken as qat'i (definitive). "
Note: in terms of narration, hadith is of two kinds -
1. Mutawatir
This is a hadith whose narrators in every era are countless. There is no room for falsehood in it.
2. Khabar wahid
This is a hadith whose narrators are one, two or three, but never reaching the mutawatir level.
I hope you have now learned what a khabar wahid is. Now I will explain the above-mentioned usul, or principle, of the Hanafi madhhab -
Suppose a ruling has come in the Holy Quran and the ruling is an entirely 'amm (general) discussion. The rule is that another verse of the Quran or a hadith will make the 'amm (general) ruling khass (specific).
Now if a khabar wahid hadith wants to make the 'amm (general) ruling of the Quran khass (specific), then in this case it will not be acceptable. Because in the principles of hadith, a khabar wahid gives 'ilm zanni (probable, doubt-prone knowledge). It does not give anything qat'i, or certain. Even if the hadith is authentic in terms of the narrator or in every respect.
Now I present an example of the above principle from the Quran and Hadith -
1. In the Holy Quran, in verse 77 of Surah al-Hajj, Allah the Exalted says -
اركعوا وواسجدوا
Bow down and prostrate.
Note that in the above verse Allah the Exalted has given a general ('amm) announcement to prostrate. How to prostrate, or which limbs are included in prostration, is not stated anywhere in the Quran. And in simple terms, prostration is satisfied just by touching the forehead to the ground.
2. In an authentic hadith it has come that the Messenger ﷺ said, I have been commanded to prostrate on seven limbs. First, the forehead. Then the Messenger ﷺ gestured and said, the two hands, the two knees and the heels of the two feet, and so on. (Bukhari; 154)
Now note, in the Quran only prostration is mentioned. But in this hadith it has come - prostration must be through the joining of seven limbs with the ground. So it is found that this hadith comes and makes the 'amm ruling of the Quran khass, or specific.
We found the 'amm (general) ruling of the Quran and the khass (specific) discussion of the hadith.
At this point Imam al-A'zam Abu Hanifa (RA) says, in this case we will give priority to the 'amm ruling of the Quran. We will not give priority to the khass ruling of the hadith over the 'amm ruling. Because the hadith is not of the mutawatir level; rather, it is khabar wahid. If the hadith were mutawatir, there would have been no obstacle to accepting it. Because a mutawatir hadith gives 'ilm yaqin (certain knowledge) while a khabar wahid gives 'ilm zanni.
Note: in this principle, Imam al-A'zam Abu Hanifa (RA) does not treat a khabar wahid as fard but accepts it as sunnah.
Final word, from the above discussion we understood that a hadith being merely authentic, or being in Bukhari, does not make it fit for practice. Rather, some more matters remain. And among those remaining matters this is one of the foremost!
On whether a khabar wahid hadith can be accepted despite being authentic, there is huge disagreement among the imams. Imam al-A'zam Abu Hanifa (RA) says, a khabar wahid can be accepted through five conditions; otherwise it cannot be accepted even though it is authentic.
Now, you perhaps do not know the khabar wahid, do not know the mutawatir, do not know the conditions for accepting a wahid. But you only saw that the hadith is authentic or came in Bukhari / Muslim; but Abu Hanifa (RA) did not accept it.
Then will you say, Abu Hanifa does not know hadith? Hadith did not reach Abu Hanifa? Abu Hanifa is a weak narrator? Abu Hanifa is against hadith?
Beware! Never make false assumptions about the Salaf of the Ummah out of your own ignorance. They gave fatwas with vast scholarship in the Quran and Hadith. They gave their verdicts after weighing everything from all sides. In the discussed ruling, see, he perhaps did not accept a khabar wahid hadith as fard, but did he not act on the Quran? Then with what conscience will you say that the Hanafi madhhab means being against the Quran and Hadith??
Rahimakallah ya Aba Hanifa
Hayyakumullah