Chapter Three · The Hanafi Madhhab

Are the Hadiths of the Hanafi Madhhab Weak? 2

From the fourth century AH, that is, the Abbasid era, the completeness, fame and following of the four madhhabs began in full swing. From then, for roughly an era, the madhhab was practised. Independent books were written on each madhhab and a huge service was done. May Allah grant those scholars the best reward _ Ameen!

In modern times the great uproar against the madhhab began. Although their number was very negligible. In particular, they set about trying to prove that the hadiths Abu Hanifa (RA) referred to in rulings were weak or da'if.

The main reason behind this was __ the lack of integrated knowledge between usul al-hadith and usul al-fiqh ((the principles of hadith and fiqh)). Those who researched hadith alone and ignored usul al-fiqh were in essence the ones who set about proving the hadiths of the imams of the madhhabs weak or da'if.

In truth, every branch of knowledge has a principle. Just as hadith has principles, so does fiqh. For those who judge, or conduct the tahqiq of, a hadith keeping the principles of both in front of them, there should be no conflict. And for those who have not done an integrated tahqiq of both, doubt is bound to arise.

This piece is arranged around one excellent proof of exactly that. This is a very subtle matter of the Hanafi madhhab, yet if you read with attention I hope you will understand, insha Allah. Allah is the Granter of success!

Topic - The hadith of a majhul (unknown) narrator

Suppose a narrator (relator of hadith) has all the qualities of acceptability. Only, unclarity remains about his 'adalah. That is, whether he is 'adil (upright) or fasiq (wicked) __ is not known. If he is 'adil his hadith is acceptable; and if he is fasiq his hadith is rejected __ this is a matter of consensus. But the question is ___ what is the ruling if nothing is known about his 'adalah??? If no other hadith is found, will the hadith of such a narrator be acceptable or not in this case?

[[ Please, if you have not understood the question, read the paragraph above again and again ]]

On this matter the honoured jurists are divided into two groups -

1. In the view of Abu Hanifa (RH), some of the Shafi'is (RH) and his companions, the report / hadith of such a narrator is acceptable in fiqh rulings.

Source - Irshad Tullab al-Haqa'iq 112

2. In the view of Imam al-Shafi'i and some of the Maliki and Hanbali imams, the report / hadith of such a narrator is unacceptable in fiqh rulings.

Source - al-Mustasfa 1 / 19

On accepting the hadith of such a narrator - one whose 'adalah is unclear - there are two groups among the usul scholars. What was acceptable to one group was unacceptable to the other. But both sides have strong evidences or proofs -

1. The evidence of Imam Abu Hanifa (RH) and his companions. They presented five evidences in all; I present two of them -

(a) Once in Madinah the Messenger ﷺ accepted the testimony of a village man about sighting the moon. Yet the Messenger ﷺ knew nothing about that village man except that he was a Muslim.

Source: the hadith is in Abu Dawud -2340, Tirmidhi - 291, Nasa'i -2111 and Ibn Majah -1652

They say, see - if knowing the 'adalah were absolutely essential, then the Messenger ﷺ would never have accepted that village man's testimony about the moon without knowing his 'adalah.

(b) After the death of the Messenger ﷺ the honoured Companions (RA) accepted narrations of hadith from countless village people, slaves and women. Yet the honoured Companions did not know much about their 'adalah.

Source: Rawdat an-Nazir - 138

2. The evidence of the Shafi'i, Maliki and Hanbali imams (RA). They too presented five evidences in all; among them I present two -

(a) The agreement on accepting a khabar wahid is _ the narrator must be 'adil. And since nothing at all is known about that narrator's 'adalah, his khabar wahid or hadith cannot be accepted.

(b) Just as such a narrator is not acceptable as a witness in a court, so too he is not acceptable in the acceptance of hadith.

In short, since both sides have strong evidences, the hadith of such a narrator is acceptable for one side and not acceptable for the other. And the matter is so hard to grasp that the author of "Rawdat an-Nazir" (RH) did not give preference to either view.

So if a proof is presented by taking a hadith from such a narrator, in the light of the evidence it will be sound in the Hanafi madhhab and unsound in the madhhabs of the others. Neither may be belittled, and no view may be called unsound.

Now to the main discussion -

You have clearly understood from the above discussion that the evidentiary discussion of both sides is strong. Now if Imam Abu Hanifa (RH) presents the khabar wahid hadith of such a narrator as istidlal, or evidence, on some ruling, will the hadith then be da'if? Will it be rejected? Will it not be fit for practice?

Final word, because they are unfamiliar with such principles, or because they belong to a different madhhab, some brothers wholesale call the hadiths used as istidlal by the Hanafi madhhab da'if or weak. And some brothers in our country, without understanding, spread the matter with a great drumbeat. I pray that the Lord, the Most Merciful, may grant us correct understanding!

To learn in detail, read the 'Mustasfa' of Imam al-Ghazali (RH). Read the 'Rawdat an-Nazir' of Ibn Qudamah (RH). The page numbers are respectively - 1/29 and 136

Allahumma salli ala Muhammad