Are the Hadiths of the Hanafi Madhhab Weak? 1
In recent times the Ummah has fallen into a huge trouble. That most of the hadiths that Abu Hanifa (RA), the famous imam of the four madhhabs, referred to in rulings and issues are supposedly da'if, or weak __ such a hugely ignorant slander is spreading. Those who are spreading it, even while knowing the truth without doubt, are spreading falsehood and slander only under the influence of envy. May Allah grant everyone guidance __ Ameen!
Anyway, in today's piece I will discuss the chain of hadith. Although the matter is confined to the people of knowledge, I hope everyone will find the piece easy to read.
The main point -
We know that the weakness of a hadith occurs from two sides. One, from the side of the narrator or relator. Two, from the side of the matn, or the hadith text itself. My review is from the side of the chain.
We should know that Imam al-A'zam Abu Hanifa (RA) came into the world over a hundred years before the birth of Imam al-Bukhari (RA). And we also know that, in the view of most muhaddithin, Imam Abu Hanifa is a Tabi'i. According to some he took teaching in the company of four, and according to others seven, Companions.
Suppose,
Imam Abu Hanifa is a Tabi'i. Then it can be said that if he takes a hadith from someone, there are at most two levels between the narrator and the Messenger ﷺ. Tabi'i → Companion → Messenger ﷺ.
Note:
A Companion means one who saw the Messenger ﷺ.
A Tabi'i means one who saw a Companion.
Suppose,
Imam al-Bukhari (RA) is a Tabi' al-Tabi'in. Then it can be said that if he takes a hadith, there are at least four levels between the narrator and the Messenger. Narrator → Tabi' al-Tabi'in → Tabi'i → Companion → Messenger ﷺ.
Now see a chart review,
Well, suppose a hadith is narrated in this order -
The Messenger ﷺ
↓
Umar ibn al-Khattab (RA)
↓
Alqama ibn Waqqas
↓
Yahya ibn Sa'id
↓
Sufyan ibn Uyaynah
↓
Mu'ammal ibn Isma'il
↓
Imam al-Bukhari (RA)
I hope you understand from the chart that a hadith has reached Imam al-Bukhari from the Messenger ﷺ.
Now let us discuss the grade of this hadith with Imam Abu Hanifa and Bukhari -
In brief,
The hadith is authentic with Imam Abu Hanifa (RA) and weak with Bukhari (RA). And the decision of both is sound, or authentic.
How can you say that?
Yes, so now try to understand with deep attention.
The hadith is authentic, or sound, with Imam Abu Hanifa (RA) -
Because he took the hadith from Alqama (RA). Because Abu Hanifa (RA) met him in his lifetime and took instruction from him. And by agreement, Alqama (RA) is a thiqa, or reliable narrator. So Abu Hanifa's taking of the hadith is authentic, or sound. Because up to him there is no problem in the chain of the hadith or among the narrators.
The hadith is weak, or da'if, with Imam al-Bukhari -
Because he took the hadith from Mu'ammal ibn Isma'il. And since Mu'ammal is criticised on the matter of memory, Imam al-Bukhari (RA) did not place the hadith he narrated in "Sahih al-Bukhari". Although all the narrators from "Umar ibn al-Khattab" to "Sufyan ibn Uyaynah" are thiqa, only because of "Mu'ammal ibn Isma'il" Imam al-Bukhari (RA) did not place the hadith in "Sahih al-Bukhari".
Now think deeply and tell me,
Is Imam Abu Hanifa's taking of the hadith unsound? Not at all! Because Imam Abu Hanifa did not even meet the narrator, Mu'ammal, because of whom Imam al-Bukhari called the hadith weak. Abu Hanifa (RA) died long before Mu'ammal's birth. Second, he took the hadith from a thiqa narrator, namely Alqama. So with peace of mind, Abu Hanifa's taking of the hadith is sound.
So in summary, in the review of the said hadith it can be said -
Imam Abu Hanifa's taking of this hadith is sound. Because he took the hadith from a thiqa narrator, namely Alqama.
And the same hadith's taking by Imam al-Bukhari is unsound. Because he heard the hadith from a weak narrator, namely Mu'ammal.
Final word,
I will request the practising Muslim brothers newly come to the religion: do not turn up your nose at merely hearing the word da'if about any hadith. Da'if does not simply mean rejected or something to turn up one's nose at. In all there are 49 kinds of da'if hadith. It is not the case that all da'if hadiths are rejected or unfit for practice. Among them are some hadiths that are fit for practice, and there are narrations from the honoured muhaddithin of practice on those da'if hadiths.
For example, Imam al-Tirmidhi (RA) says about his "Jami' al-Kabir" –
جميع ما في هذا الكتاب من الحديث فهو معمول به وقد أخد به بعض أهل العلم ما خلا حديثين...
"The hadiths I have brought in this book (sahih, hasan, da'if and so on), on every one of them there is the practice of some person of knowledge..."
From the statement of Imam al-Tirmidhi (RA) it is clearly understood that at that time, among the imams and muhaddithin, there was, for sound reasons, practice even on some da'if hadiths.
So I will say to my religious brothers: do not be alarmed upon hearing da'if hadith. Learn the tahqiq (decision) of the honoured scholars about the hadith. Then decide, insha Allah! May Allah bless your efforts _ Ameen!
An example of acting on a da'if hadith despite an authentic hadith existing
1. The hadith of Ibn Abbas (RA)
حدثنا هناد حدثنا يونس بن بكير عن محمد بن إسحاق قال: حدثني داود بن الحصين عن عكرمة عن ابن عباس قال: رد النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم ابنته زينب على أبي العاص بن الربيع بعد ست سنين بالنكاح الأول ولم يحدث نكاحا
Narrated from Ibn Abbas (RA):
He said, the Messenger of Allah ﷺ returned his daughter Zaynab to Abu al-As ibn al-Rabi' after six years, keeping the first marriage in force, and did not arrange a new marriage.
Source - Sahih Ibn Majah (2009) and Jami' at-Tirmidhi, hadith no. 1143. Grade of the hadith: Sahih hadith
Source: Al Hadith Android app,
2. The hadith of Amr ibn Shu'ayb (RA) -
حدثنا أبو معاوية عن الحجاج عن عمرو بن شعيب عن أبيه عن جده أن رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم رد ابنته زينب على أبي العاص بن الربيع بمهر جديد ونكاح جديد
Narrated successively from Amr ibn Shu'ayb (RH) from his father and grandfather - The Messenger of Allah ﷺ returned his own daughter Zaynab to Abu al-As ibn al-Rabi' by fixing a mahr again and through a new marriage.
Da'if, Ibn Majah (2010)
Footnote:
Imam Abu Isa al-Tirmidhi (RH) says: There is criticism about the chain of this hadith. But the scholars have acted according to the meaning of this hadith. If a woman accepts Islam first and her husband accepts Islam during her iddah, then the right of her former husband takes precedence. This is the opinion of Imams Malik, al-Awza'i, al-Shafi'i, Ahmad, Ishaq and others.
Jami' at-Tirmidhi, hadith no. 1142
Grade of the hadith: Weak hadith
Source: Al Hadith Android app
______________
Some special points -
1. The first hadith says that the Messenger ﷺ returned his daughter to her husband on the basis of the previous marriage, without a new marriage. And the second hadith says that she was returned with a new marriage and fixing of mahr.
2. The first hadith is fully authentic in terms of chain, and the second hadith is defective, that is, da'if. But in this ruling, despite an authentic hadith existing, there is practice on the da'if hadith.
3. When to act on an authentic hadith and when on a da'if hadith is not to be judged by one's own knowledge. It is to be left to the ijtihad of the muhaddiths and mujtahid imams.
4. It is not that all authentic hadiths are fit for practice, nor that all da'if hadiths are to be rejected. Rather, depending on the case it may be the opposite. So if a mujtahid imam gives a ruling on a da'if hadith, despite an authentic hadith existing, on the basis of his own ijtihad, do not needlessly slander or go to excess.