Introduction

Readers' Opinions

Readers' Opinions

1

All praise is for Allah. Thousands of blessings and peace upon our beloved Prophet, Muhammad ﷺ. Today in our country, one subject is the cause of debate, criticism and hate-filled talk, and a huge rift has opened within the Ummah. It is only over the madhhab. What really is the madhhab? Is the madhhab outside the Quran and Hadith? Not at all. In truth, the madhhab is built from the Quran and the Sunnah. Yet many of us say, "When we have the Quran and Hadith, what need is there for a madhhab?" In reality, because our knowledge of the madhhab is limited, we say such things out of ignorance. Because we have no correct idea of the madhhab, we fall into confusion. Even through misunderstanding, we are splitting into various groups and opinions. As Muslims, being divided into groups is not what we want. So Shaykh Abdul Karim al-Madani (may Allah preserve him) of the University of Madinah, Saudi Arabia, has, amid a very busy schedule, given us a gift: a timely mobile app of discussions on the madhhab, resolving all the problems on this subject. I hope that those of us who are completely ignorant about the madhhab, and those who oppose it without understanding or knowing, and who present objectionable arguments against it, will be able to understand and learn about the madhhab very easily. Not only that, many think the madhhab exists only in India, Pakistan and Bangladesh. The interesting thing is that through this app you will learn that the Arab countries follow the madhhab. This app discusses the madhhab beautifully and uses our simple mother tongue. It also presents the real picture of the Arab countries and lectures by various Arab shaykhs. I was amazed to see the Shaykh's discussion of the madhhab. May Allah grant all of us the ability to understand. O Most Merciful Lord, accept the service of Shaykh Abdul Karim al-Madani (may Allah preserve him). Grant the Shaykh a good life and blessing in his knowledge, and forgive me. Ameen.

"I will be happy and joyful forever

On the day Allah announces that He has forgiven me"

Nur-Alam Rumi

2

When electricity suddenly comes on, at first the eyes cannot be fully opened. A person who comes from darkness into the light of the religion faces several problems at first. One of the foremost is the problem of the "madhhab".

We all know that the foundation of our Islam is the Quran and the Sunnah. When this thought comes to mind, the brain counterattacks: "Then why the madhhab? What need is there to follow it? The Quran and Hadith are there, and we only need to act on them directly." It is hard to find anyone returning to the faith who has not fallen into this web of error.

When the question circles in our heads, we turn to the company of a shaykh: "Shaykh Google". It is said, "There is nothing in the world that is not on Google." So a person returning to the faith searches there and finds a great deal.

Then they think, "What need is there to go in person and sit with a teacher (ustadh)?" Yet no one even knows which site or source the answer from Google comes from. They simply grab whatever they find. Many search Google, read some anti-madhhab writing, and abandon the madhhab altogether. Others, finding no satisfying answer, are left in doubt about following it, and at some point they too give it up entirely.

Now let me speak a little about myself. Although I grew up in a Muslim family, I grew up like the members of any eight or ten ordinary Muslim families. At one point, alhamdulillah, I became very inclined towards the religion. Then I resolved: "No, I must not spend this fleeting world like this; I must spend my life worshipping Allah." Right after returning to the faith, the trouble I faced was over following the "madhhab". Whenever I had difficulty understanding something, I went to my childhood ustadh. This time I did the same.

When I went to my ustadh and asked about the madhhab, he did not give it much importance. I kept saying, "I need to know why I should follow it. For what reason? What did the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say?" Many more questions were circling in my head. He tried to explain but failed, and the answers were not satisfying.

In the meantime I met some more religious friends. I used to meet them, and we spent good time together. One day they said to me, "What is the point of following a madhhab? The Quran and Sunnah are our foundation." The statement sounded logical to me: "True enough." But then I said, "But there are many fiqh matters that the imams have explained. The madhhab has made things easy for me, and I get fatwas easily. And our forefathers have been following the madhhab too."

Surprisingly, one of them said to me, "If your father and grandfather make a mistake, will you make it too?" I was trapped in a web of words. For one day I could neither say anything nor bear it. They also said, "Not all knowledge reached the imams. They said that if anything of theirs conflicts with it, we should drop it and accept the authentic hadith." After hearing this, I said, "All right, I will look into it further."

After returning home I began searching again. "Why? Why? Why must I follow the madhhab?" Helpless, I searched on Google, Facebook, YouTube, to see whether any book existed. The sad thing is, "I did not find a satisfying answer anywhere!"

Later I reassured myself: "Surely the imams were not wrong. Surely they did not give fatwas casually. And if the imams had been ordinary people, the people of the whole world would not have followed their fiqh for generation after generation." I stayed fixed on this: "No! I will follow the madhhab. If someone does not, that is their affair." After that I avoided conversations on this subject.

Reader! This is the story of one small problem in my life. If this happened to me, do you not think that hundreds of thousands of people returning to the faith are stuck in this problem and cannot find their way out? Surely, "Yes!"

Abdul Karim. A very beautiful name, mashaAllah! He was born in a rural area of Sylhet. He studied in madrasas from childhood. Then he set out for the heart of the Muslim Ummah, "Madinah", to the university called the "Islamic University of Madinah". He is studying Sharia there.

I met the brother on the 25th of September 2020. He is handsome and well-built. As long as I talked with him, I felt I was speaking with the waters of a calm ocean. With the touch of gentleness in his words, I seemed to melt. I had thrown many questions at him, and alhamdulillah, that day I got satisfying answers to all of them.

Lately, brother Abdul Karim has been writing about the madhhab on his Facebook account. Most people in Bangladesh follow the Hanafi madhhab. The sad thing is that, apart from those with a madrasa background, no one with a general education knows much about the madhhab. We have been practising it by learning from our elders. Some, after coming to the religion, have abandoned the madhhab. They throw question after question, or some quoted statement or other, at those who follow the madhhab, and hearing it a person falls into confusion.

Brother Abdul Karim is writing about Hanafi fiqh. Good discussion is taking place around it. A question may arise: "Is the brother writing to put others down?" The answer is, "No, not at all." Rather, he is writing for followers of the Hanafi madhhab, so that if they have any doubt or question in their minds they can get answers and follow the madhhab without worry. He has also refuted/rebutted the false claims made about the madhhab and about Imam Abu Hanifa (rahimahullah).

This responsibility should have been taken up by learned scholars. But sadly, it is a student of knowledge who is writing on this subject, and because of his writing many people today are becoming clear about the madhhab. They are getting answers to the questions hidden in their hearts. Their doubts are being removed. Reading these writings, a person's idea of the madhhab is becoming as clear as clean water, alhamdulillah.

In his writing, brother Abdul Karim did not merely state his own views. He brought the "words" of the learned and great scholars of the Ummah, with references, showing "why the madhhab must be followed and for whom it is essential. He has discussed fiqh somewhat. He has also discussed the principles of fiqh." After reading the brother's writing, some people felt that it was against them, but that is not so. He is presenting in his own way, with evidence and proof, and it is outstanding.

I have given the brother's writings to many to read. I asked them personally, "How have you benefited from reading Abdul Karim's writing?" In summary, the answer I got from all was, "Alhamdulillah! Everything is becoming clear."

The brother's writings cannot but be praised. The amount we are benefiting from them cannot be put into words. I was delighted to hear that an app is coming out of the brother's writings on the madhhab. I pray to Allah, "May Allah make brother Abdul Karim a means of serving the Ummah in even greater works, ameen."

Lastly, I will say this: read the brother's writings calmly and with balance. If you follow a madhhab, read them for your own improvement; and if you do not follow a madhhab, read them with an open mind and verify them.

The Muslim Ummah has reached a state where, instead of uniting against the disbelievers, we are dying in internal strife. May Allah grant us the ability to unite and give us correct and beneficial knowledge, ameen.

"Allahummaghfirli"

  • Wahidul Hadi

Living in France